Montana,
I am not calling out one person. Not even sure if it matters, frankly I am sure we all are happy to be wrong about a player if we are predicting them failing.
I myself was sure we were wasting time starting a rookie QB when rookie QBs don't EVER win in the playoffs, or often even go. And I was sure we had such a good defense that we would be squandering wins with a rookie QB. Yep, I was against starting Wilson - so not sure I can rub it in your face....I was a 100x more wrong.
BUT Browner has busted tail for us, and it drove me nuts to see so many people up in arms about him getting a well deserved raise - even though I was really really hoping we had extended him instead. I still think that is going to bite us in the butt almost as badly as the not resigning Hutch thing did.
When a wideout goes across the middle people talk about how tough they have to be, how they have to have their head on a swivel because a safety can just rub them out. The thing is, that Browner can and does put the same kind of punishment on guys on the ends. So now you cannot just avoid the safeties and be sure of not getting hit as hard. Also, Browner cleans up against the run pretty well too and if someone breaks loose he is a bit tougher for a WR to block because he is so big and physical. This means that if you are a WR you are thinking about where the guy is, because if you get loose he will probably drill you before you hit the ground. Maybe if you keep him close you can catch it anyway, but not if he is getting adept at stripping the ball loose.
He doesn't have the quickest hips like some corners, but he brings to WR the fear of being hurt (though not intentional injuries) to the mix. It is a complete X factor that is hard to practice for and hard to duplicate. The guy who called him the Punisher was spot on, maybe a guy like Andre Waters was like him or Rodney Harrison, but those guys were more guys that launched themselves at players, not run through them like Browner does. Even then I've never really seen a player that looked like he wanted to rip someone's arms off when he tackled, at least not since the 80s.
The idea that Thurmond or anyone else can replicate that is crazy.