This is bordering on unhinged, dude.
I think he's a top-10 quarterback talent (arm, fundamentals, and athleticism) whose performance hasn't been top-10, mostly due to the situations he's had to operate in for 3 years now.
I have no idea why you feel the need to make this a weird mob mentality thing. If there is a "Geno is elite" crowd, it is a MASSIVE minority, and that's beyond obvious and can CERTAINLY be proven if you wanna throw a poll up.
Actually, I did that already. You know what we proved?
No one actually has a consistent viewpoint on Geno and they change how they feel after every few games based on his most recent performances.
I totally disagree with a bunch of these. Jordan Love has had a good half a season. He hasn't earned A tier status yet. Goff is not A tier, he's B tier. Prescott, Smith and Stafford belong on A tier. You're allowed to. Go and make your own.
www.seahawks.net
So this whole premise is flawed and gives people way too much credit, as if most people even have a real opinion to begin with on the topic.