TeamoftheCentury":3gszg08f said:
I wouldn't agree that Kasen has made the team yet. Has shown his value, but McEvoy is more polished, has softer hands, runs better routes and overall better special teamer. Punt blocking, he can do it all.
Has Williams shown much over the middle? I like the effort by Kasen with the opportunities he's being given. But, dropping that pass in the bread basket? They already know what they've got with McEvoy. Who is the better blocking WR?
I like Kasen, but would be a mistake to part with McEvoy.
I'm more with this.
Kasen basically has only produced with the fade route. I want to see him do other routes. His release is always the same. He can't just be a fade specialist.
I'm not ready to say he's made the team until he can demonstrate he can be an even halfway complete WR. Need to see more.
McEvoy is a better ST player, and can be featured at WR and TE. Bigger. Shows more complete ability. Kasen however does show a very real ability for the red line fade. And that's a pattern Seattle LOVES.
Tough call. But right now I gotta go with McEvoy. But that's pretty soft.