Did Darboh get injured last night.
I am hoping that Williams makes the 53, he's proven to me anyway, that he can produce.
I am hoping that Williams makes the 53, he's proven to me anyway, that he can produce.
I believe Kearse caught at least other ball. A 20 yrdr over the middle.Seymour":26kgzvu7 said:vin.couve12":26kgzvu7 said:Kinds of amazed at that objectivity there. That pass was actually on RW.
I've been tough on Kearse since last year, but I have to admit....Russell seams cursed when throwing to Kearse. Whatever chemistry they once had, is now completely gone.
pmedic920":1zwjr8u7 said:Did Darboh get injured last night.
I am hoping that Williams makes the 53, he's proven to me anyway, that he can produce.
getnasty":3r0cfm0z said:Baldwin, Lockett, Kearse, Richardson, Williams, Darboh.
TeamoftheCentury":1fl9k0oa said:I wouldn't agree that Kasen has made the team yet. Has shown his value, but McEvoy is more polished, has softer hands, runs better routes and overall better special teamer. Punt blocking, he can do it all.
Has Williams shown much over the middle? I like the effort by Kasen with the opportunities he's being given. But, dropping that pass in the bread basket? They already know what they've got with McEvoy. Who is the better blocking WR?
I like Kasen, but would be a mistake to part with McEvoy.
TeamoftheCentury":2svcjqkx said:I like Kasen, but would be a mistake to part with McEvoy.
I'll answer in a way I hope will defuse. In general, McEvoy seems to run more of the fuller route tree and Williams tends to run the 9 or "go". That's what is asked of him with his skill set and he has shown he does it very well. McEvoy is 6-5/230 and is able to make those grabs while making them look more routine. He is more fluid. In addition to running more of the route tree, he has a knack for finding space and getting separation. Williams (with less speed?) seems to always be tightly covered and contested.The Breh":6plbaubb said:TeamoftheCentury":6plbaubb said:I wouldn't agree that Kasen has made the team yet. Has shown his value, but McEvoy is more polished, has softer hands, runs better routes and overall better special teamer. Punt blocking, he can do it all.
Has Williams shown much over the middle? I like the effort by Kasen with the opportunities he's being given. But, dropping that pass in the bread basket? They already know what they've got with McEvoy. Who is the better blocking WR?
I like Kasen, but would be a mistake to part with McEvoy.
Runs better routes ?
You guys really throw this idea out there fairly often like you are calling the plays yourselves and know where they're supposed to run.
I'm not tryin to attack here, just trying to understand how you come to this conclusion.
Do you rewind plays and somehow see where every receiver ran even when they're off screen and decide one dude ran "crisper" than the other ?
On a vertical view at that. If you had a sky cam and looking down you could actually see the route. Looking from a side view, you must have some amazing intuition and should be on the staff.
I'm genuinely intrigued, please enlighten me :irishdrinkers:
Not just speed. Savvy. McEvoy most certainly has shown he is very athletic and makes high-pointing the ball look effortless. He showed that last year.The Breh":1j12b692 said:Well, you bring up route tree. Again, like you have the opportunity to see everywhere these guys run.
Williams being tightly covered may be strictly dependent on the DB in coverage.
I find it hard to believe at 6'5 230 McEvoy is better at getting separation based on speed. He was left wide open last year for that TD, maybe people just don't respect him ?
Williams has been making contested catches the past 2 weeks. If it came down to it, I'd like the guy who's proven to battle for the ball in the air.
McEvoy hasn't shown that.
Matter of fact, I don't know the last time we've seen anybody fight for balls like Kasen. Some of that may be on Russ' throws too, namely that TD.
For the record, I'm a big McEvoy fan and want to see him around. These are two very different players tho.
sutz":2h004i9b said:That's actually on Russ, not Kearse. He threw the ball behind him, not to the pylon like he should have. With Williams, he threw the ball high enough for him to go up and get it.Coug_Hawk08":2h004i9b said:I really enjoyed his TD. Throw to Kearse in back corner of end zone, 100% fail (same as last year). Next play, throw to Kasen in back for of end zone, TD.
He is definitely working hard for a spot! If we don't cut Kearse, I don't see Darboh making it over Kasen.
But agreed, Kasem needs to make the 53. If it's at Kearse's expense, I can live with it. Kearse has made some great clutch catches for us over the years, but he's had his share of drops, too. I doubt he gets cut, though, both from the roster perspective and the money we owe him.
TeamoftheCentury":3rix8hiw said:Not just speed. Savvy. McEvoy most certainly has shown he is very athletic and makes high-pointing the ball look effortless. He showed that last year.The Breh":3rix8hiw said:Well, you bring up route tree. Again, like you have the opportunity to see everywhere these guys run.
Williams being tightly covered may be strictly dependent on the DB in coverage.
I find it hard to believe at 6'5 230 McEvoy is better at getting separation based on speed. He was left wide open last year for that TD, maybe people just don't respect him ?
Williams has been making contested catches the past 2 weeks. If it came down to it, I'd like the guy who's proven to battle for the ball in the air.
McEvoy hasn't shown that.
Matter of fact, I don't know the last time we've seen anybody fight for balls like Kasen. Some of that may be on Russ' throws too, namely that TD.
For the record, I'm a big McEvoy fan and want to see him around. These are two very different players tho.
My contention is McEvoy offers more. Kasen looks to be earning a roster spot somewhere if not Seattle.
Cheers!
The Breh":3ip5pw6p said:Well, you bring up route tree. Again, like you have the opportunity to see everywhere these guys run.
Williams being tightly covered may be strictly dependent on the DB in coverage.
I find it hard to believe at 6'5 230 McEvoy is better at getting separation based on speed. He was left wide open last year for that TD, maybe people just don't respect him ?
Williams has been making contested catches the past 2 weeks. If it came down to it, I'd like the guy who's proven to battle for the ball in the air.
McEvoy hasn't shown that.
Matter of fact, I don't know the last time we've seen anybody fight for balls like Kasen. Some of that may be on Russ' throws too, namely that TD.
For the record, I'm a big McEvoy fan and want to see him around. These are two very different players tho.