Poll: QB 2025

[Aircrew]

I say we go with the most cost effective guy under center and invest in the O line for the next 2-3 years.

 

[oldhawkfan]

It’s my understanding that Geno is under contract for next year. None of it is guaranteed. This poll is meaningless. Wishful thinking at best.

 

[toffee]

Toffee at this point I'm not sure if you're trolling or what but I haven't seen a sea of people claiming Howell is the answer but I think you know that.

You tell us, would you pay Geno 45-55 million next year? If not who is your choice?

This constant Geno supporter or GeNO thing I don't understand. Most people are fine with Geno for the right price. That should be everyone's answer even if we disagree on what that price is.

Geno is a goner, when he is not putting butts on seats in our stadium, his days are limited. Geno wants his last long-term contract, he has been saving his body for that contract, but he is not likely to get that from the Hawks. He might reluctantly come back to finish his contract or a deeply discounted 1+1 or 1+2 if he couldn't find other opportunities, but the Hawks ought to resist. Why? Geno could be checked out on these discount contracts on the business front and he has been hearing steps on football field.

Drew, Sam and Justin might be our only choices.

 

[SoulfishHawk]

YOUNG

 

[Chukarhawk]

None of those are options. I still need to see Howell actually play after taking snaps with the 1st team to form a real opinion. I'm not going to dismiss the guy from 1 half of football. Drew lock and Fields are trash. I'd stay Geno at that point.

 

[BGHawk]

Any one of these guys could be the guy given a half a chance..sometimes it takes more than a half of a game to find thier footing/ rhythm..to feel comfortable running the first team. In several years we will see how they pan out..they just might not be with the team then. It's hard to know.

 

[Scout]

I voted Howell because the new coaching staff along with JS are all in with him up to this point and see him in practice everyday. Howell is on a cheaper contract and 4 years younger than Lock while having a year under his belt in this offensive system.

 

[toffee]

YOUNG

Howell is the youngest of the three!!

 

[SoulfishHawk]

Not if you do what I asked and add 2 more names hahahahahahah

JJ MCCARTHY
SAM DARNOLD

Make it happen, kid

 

[toffee]

Not if you do what I asked and add 2 more names hahahahahahah

JJ MCCARTHY
SAM DARNOLD

Make it happen, kid

The Vikings are not releasing Darnold after his one good season, they are not cutting McCarthy either as he is on a rookie contract. umm, you like them young? Howell is it.

 

[SoulfishHawk]

Come on home slice, just put the 2 damn names on there. I promise I won't call you geTOFF
Getting McCarthy is VERY much a possibility. And there's nothing saying that Darnold can't be had as well. Go anti-Toffee and be UN-stubborn for once hahahaha.

And for the record, YOUNG is a Toffee-ism. And a good one.

 

[GemCity]

I vote none of the above. Play Geno and keep drafting QBs til you find one.

I agree with you but the flaw in this statement is ‘…keep drafting QBs’.

It’s something they rarely do. THAT needs to change.

 

[TheLegendOfBoom]

I agree with you but the flaw in this statement is ‘…keep drafting QBs’.

It’s something they rarely do. THAT needs to change.

Not drafting Guards early ALSO needs to change! Hopefully, Seattle, can draft a blue chip interior offensive lineman, this time!

 

[Rat]

Not drafting Guards early ALSO needs to change! Hopefully, Seattle, can draft a blue chip interior offensive lineman, this time!

Who did we miss out on last year? The first guard didn't go until the mid-second, and the second didn't go until a few picks before we took Haynes. The only center to go early-ish was by Tampa with the 26th pick. Should we have passed on Murphy for him?

 

[TheLegendOfBoom]

Who did we miss out on last year? The first guard didn't go until the mid-second, and the second didn't go until a few picks before we took Haynes. The only center to go early-ish was by Tampa with the 26th pick. Should we have passed on Murphy for him?

High pick isn’t necessarily only first round.

Second round pick also considered a high pick.

I wanted O’Cyrus Torrence back in 2023 but Seattle picked up Charbonnet instead.

Torrence is now a full-time starter in Buffalo and protects well enough for Josh Allen, and Seattle has a part-time starter at RB instead.

 

[Cyrus12]

Voting for these options should be a crime...

 

[Torc]

Keep Geno and Howell. If Geno plays well enough next year, franchise him.
Sign Daniel Jones.
Draft a prospect.

It's stupid to only have two NFL quality QBs on the roster. Maybe there'd be more good QBs in the league if they didn't just swing, miss and release high draft picks. More development can only help the position.

 

[toffee]

Keep Geno and Howell. If Geno plays well enough next year, franchise him.
Sign Daniel Jones.
Draft a prospect.

It's stupid to only have two NFL quality QBs on the roster. Maybe there'd be more good QBs in the league if they didn't just swing, miss and release high draft picks. More development can only help the position.

Adding Daniel Jones to the poll.

 

[HawkinNY]

None of them

 

[Rat]

High pick isn’t necessarily only first round.

Second round pick also considered a high pick.

I wanted O’Cyrus Torrence back in 2023 but Seattle picked up Charbonnet instead.

Torrence is now a full-time starter in Buffalo and protects well enough for Josh Allen, and Seattle has a part-time starter at RB instead.

We traded our last one for ten games of Leonard Williams.