MontanaHawk05":1hfsq5k3 said:
Steve2222":1hfsq5k3 said:
Wilson would shred defenses with Ryan's supporting cast. Hell he would shred defenses with all those teams supporting cast. All of them have good to great OLs.
Rodgers and Roethlisberger have made it to the playoffs in years when their OL is terrible. And Brady and Ryan just get rid of the ball fast, which forces defenses to back off and makes protection easier.
So I did some analysis on Roth, Rodgers and Wilson
During their careers the avg ranking of their olines in pass protection is as follows
Rodgers 20th
Roths 20th
Wilson 26th
Worst ranking was 32nd Wilson
Best ranking 4th Rothesburger
Worst ranking winning a WB Wilsons 24th
Best ranking winning an SB 21st Rodgers
Only Wilson has never had an oline ranked above 15th in pass blocking
Only Wilson has never had an oline ranked above 20th in pass blocking
Now Brady and Ryan I only did the last 5 years for them as they were more also adds by the OP
Brady avg ranking 8th worse 18th best 2nd
Ryan avg 11th, worse 23rd, best 7th.
Only 1 time between the 2 did they have an oline rank below 20th, only twice below 15th, only 3 times below 10th.
You can argue the way they play or the way the OC call the games help but not enough to discount the difference between Bradys avg ranking of 8th, Ryans of 11th and Wilsons of 26th.
Of the 5 Qbs Wilson has had to play behind the worse of the pass blocking olines and yet we have at least gotten to the DIvional round every year