D
DomeHawk
Guest
It was remarkable to see what Ken Norton did with that banged up defense. Schottenheimer just the opposite, I knew it from the day we hired him.
MontanaHawk05":wlfc3keb said:We haven't faced a good quarterback yet. I would caution against the idea that this defense is succeeding in any meaningful way. They can handle Keenum and Trubisky, but get them into a marquee matchup against an elite QB with the defensive line playing as poorly as they are, and they might have their asses fed to them. Hard to tell yet.
MontanaHawk05":28zoiq40 said:We haven't faced a good quarterback yet. I would caution against the idea that this defense is succeeding in any meaningful way. They can handle Keenum and Trubisky, but get them into a marquee matchup against an elite QB with the defensive line playing as poorly as they are, and they might have their asses fed to them. Hard to tell yet.
MontanaHawk05":3uq61nsb said:We haven't faced a good quarterback yet.
seahawkfreak":20wgybw0 said:MontanaHawk05":20wgybw0 said:We haven't faced a good quarterback yet. I would caution against the idea that this defense is succeeding in any meaningful way. They can handle Keenum and Trubisky, but get them into a marquee matchup against an elite QB with the defensive line playing as poorly as they are, and they might have their asses fed to them. Hard to tell yet.
This may be true but I am not buying the degradation of Keenum and Trubisky. Keenum had a great year last year and has brought his team to 2-0 season so far. Anyone that cannot see the talent Trubisky has is playing video games on their computer while watching the game. He will be a successful QB in the NFL, just a lot of rough edges to sand out and it looks like he has coach that can mentor him.
I'm hoping PC has had a couple of sleepless nights and has had a come to reality moment. Never heard him take blame for offensive production until this past game so hopefully we can progress. As horrible as the past two games have been and with all the injuries on defense I am surprised we haven't gotten blown out. Yet we were still in both games. Sunlight hasn't darkened yet. Really liking what our defense is doing.
austinslater25":38wsro9i said:Even if Schott is worse than Bevell that doesn't mean Bevell wasn't bad himself.
TwistedHusky":3a7o5fl1 said:It amazes me that people can look at Shoddy's record and come to any conclusion that gets them to expect reasonable results.
His entire career was mediocre production.
Some of you extrapolated wildly different production but he was not even a good enough coordinator to beat college defenses.
If you need people to make excuses for why you didn't produce, then you don't have a record of production.
We needed someone with a record of production.
Norton is looking spotty too. Crappy vs Denver. Decent against the Bears but then their QB was missing open guys all night. I know he sucked on the Raiders when he had Mack and Irvin. I wouldn't get too excited about him either but he did OK against the Bears.
Even top 15 defense is a stretch though. Once we start facing decent QBs I would like to see what the #s look like. Right now, there is nothing telling either way - just his track record in Oakland to fall back on.