Wilson was light years better than Geno and its not even remotely clos
Get there isn’t a coach in the league who would call Geno better than Herbert. You say it’s lazy to use traditional numbers but I’d argue it’s also lazy to not factor in situation too, Herbert’s has been decimated by injuries and a much worse supporting cast.
When was Wilson light years better than Geno? Because it hasn't been these past three years which seem to be the only ones we're talking about in this thread. We're comparing Russ in 2021 to Geno in 2022/2023, this has nothing to do with peak Russ. Or is that one of those specifics that these 'people' I hear about like to ignore when it doesn't fit their narrative?
And I didn't say it was lazy to use traditional numbers, I was calling the analysis lazy because it
didn't factor in situation when he was comparing Russ's 2021 to Geno's 2022-2023.
And that's not even related to my criticism of his 'rankings'. I never called Geno better than Herbert. I was asking WTF his 'rankings' were based on. What 'specific' am I supposed to be 'not ignoring' for a list of QBs that seems to have been randomly pulled from thin air? I also asked how he could rank Dak Prescott below Russell Wilson or how he could figure out where ANY college QB who hasn't even been drafted yet rates on a list of starters.
My point wasn't that any coach in the league would call Geno better than Herbert, my point was that this list clearly isn't based on recent performance because of those stats. It's not based on potential because there isn't a planet in this universe on which Russell Wilson has more potential than Dak Prescott or Tua Tagovailoa.
He also put the older, been playing worse, and recently suffered injury Stafford above the younger and better playing Goff.
The list makes no sense as a ranking based on recent play or as future projection. It seemed to be only as an exercise where he could 'prove' that Geno is a bridge by completely arbitrarily putting him low on a list of QBs that seems to be based on nothing. At that point, why not just list them alphabetically by last name? I'll bet Smith gets Geno in the bottom half of the list.