Hawknight
Well-known member
Hasselbeck did say "We want the ball, and we're going to score". That sounds like an elite QB to meWhich sb did he win?
Hasselbeck did say "We want the ball, and we're going to score". That sounds like an elite QB to meWhich sb did he win?
No. An elite QB is a 1st ballot HOFerWas Hasselbeck an elite QB?
A bridge to an absolute disappointment of a QBThe bridge to the Super Bowl, or the bridge to the next QB?
Why don't we just draft one of them?!?!?!! Are the Seahawks stupid?No. An elite QB is a 1st ballot HOFer
It's better to have a veteran take their lumps during the first year of a brand-new regime. Once the system and roster are solidified, then you insert the rookie with a strong support system in place, for his best chance at success.How does he provide “stability” in a system that is unknown to everyone at this time? Just because he may know where to park and where the bathrooms are mean nothing. If he is not part of the long term plans we should have someone who is taking their lumps during a throw away season. Not a $30m fossil QB.
Totally agree with this. Geno is not #22:First of all: Yay! Another Geno thread!
Second of all: My favorite kind of analysis! Lazy! Let's just compare Yards, TDs, INTs across seasons! And then Passer Rating as well, which is... well, yards, TDs, and INTs!
We didn't think Russ was 'washed up' in 2021 because of his numbers, Russ was washed because his 'basic' numbers hid a fundamentally inefficient player who couldn't keep our offense on the field.
Russ went from a fundamentally successful player to one who was in the bottom half in the league in success rate. (And has stayed bottom tier in success rate ever since.)
Our league worst average TOP per offensive drive was so far to the bottom of the league that the 2nd worst team in the league was as close to being league average as they were to being as bad as us.
This leads me to the worst part of this post, which is the completely ridiculous 'ranking' of all 32 QBs. What is this based on (if it's based on anything at all)? Is it just names you like?
Over the past 2 years, Geno has been better than Justin Herbert by Success Rate, Passer Rating, and ANY/A and almost identical in QBR. Yet Geno is 22 and Herbert is top 5? You have Russ above Geno for what, exactly? Tua is towards the bottom because you came up with a funny nickname for him? And are you actually trying to rank a bunch of rookies who may not even start next year?
Was any thought put into this ranking whatsoever? Or was this just an exercise in self-indulgence?
EDIT: And HTAF do you rank Dak Prescott below Russell Wilson?
I think this holds water. Geno & Dak have had considerably better weapons to work with. I believe you could put them all in the same tier with Garner being on the top.Gardner Minshew above Dak and Geno is absolute Cowherdism
If you're trying to say he didn't play well enough to win that SB, I don't even know what to say about it...Which sb did he win?
Yeah, see? Cowherdism.I think this holds water. Geno & Dak have had considerably better weapons to work with. I believe you could put them all in the same tier with Garner being on the top.
I assume you are talking about facial hair here, right?I think this holds water. Geno & Dak have had considerably better weapons to work with. I believe you could put them all in the same tier with Garner being on the top.
Matt Hasselbeck was elite . Just not 15 seasons worth. I could understand why he wouldn't make HOF but he was damn good for a minute. If Superbowl is the cutoff , there are lots of QBs not makingWhich sb did he win?
If Matt had the LOB, they would say he was elite. Sometimes I think the tragic death of Frank Shurmur kept Mike from winning another Superbowl with the Hawks.Matt Hasselbeck was elite . Just not 15 seasons worth. I could understand why he wouldn't make HOF but he was damn good for a minute. If Superbowl is the cutoff , there are lots of QBs not making
The hall of fame .
Yup. Russ managed just fine, and he was a 3rd round pick.I would rather see the rookie thrown to the wolves than watch Geno start another year or two.
That will be another two years wasted.
Geno & Dak can't or should I say haven't proven they can do anything with a team that Garner hasn't. I would like to hear your argument that Garner also did this with less play makers around him?Yeah, see? Cowherdism.