if Marshawn has 3 more good years as a Seahawk

sprhawk

New member
Joined
Apr 22, 2013
Messages
22
Reaction score
0
Agreed. Beastquake is the single best Seahawks memory I have.

That run is memoriable only because Lynch seldom tears off big runs. It was an awesome moment but looking back it was missed tackles and horrible coverage that made that play, not Lynch.

SA used to tear off huge runs every week. Sorry you missed the show. There was nothing like seeing SA make a couple of cuts and break free for a long TD run.
 

pcbball12

New member
Joined
Mar 28, 2011
Messages
736
Reaction score
0
That run is memoriable only because Lynch seldom tears off big runs. It was an awesome moment but looking back it was missed tackles and horrible coverage that made that play, not Lynch.

SA used to tear off huge runs every week. Sorry you missed the show. There was nothing like seeing SA make a couple of cuts and break free for a long TD run.

This post is going to get eaten alive.....and rightfully so.
 

Chapow

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 11, 2010
Messages
6,130
Reaction score
2,159
The Radish":2osiidt1 said:
I love Beastmode for sure but like many others know he's not the type of runner that has a really long career.

However look at Rick Watters, he was a basher for 3 different teams and was very good right up to the last season. Lets hope it works out like that for Marshawn.

:les:


Except for the 3 different teams part right? ;)
 

Chapow

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 11, 2010
Messages
6,130
Reaction score
2,159
Agreed. Beastquake is the single best Seahawks memory I have.[/quote]

That run is memoriable only because Lynch seldom tears off big runs. It was an awesome moment but looking back it was missed tackles and horrible coverage that made that play, not Lynch.

SA used to tear off huge runs every week. Sorry you missed the show. There was nothing like seeing SA make a couple of cuts and break free for a long TD run.[/quote]


Why dude, why did you have to do that?
 

grizrgood

New member
Joined
Dec 20, 2012
Messages
92
Reaction score
0
Location
Selah, Washington
TwilightError":2jdk2jx0 said:
Shaz":2jdk2jx0 said:
Lynch has already wrapped up his legacy as one of the most exciting and memorable Seahawks player ever

His Beast Quake run is arguably the greatest play in Franchise history

Agreed. Beastquake is the single best Seahawks memory I have. If he brings us a ring, I will demand a statue for the man. Not a look-a-like statue but some sort af a massive beast like figure.

Yep! The way that man plays the game of football is more than I could ever wished for in a Seahawk running back. I say give him a statue now!
 

sprhawk

New member
Joined
Apr 22, 2013
Messages
22
Reaction score
0
Because it's not cool to overshadow a ring of honor player with a need fill player that turned out to be better than expected

Lynch helped to get us thru a tough time but as far as RB's go, the truth is he is average.

As a fan I hope he has another good season but he is a 27 year old powerback in his 8th NFL season.

Its Turbin time.
 

grizrgood

New member
Joined
Dec 20, 2012
Messages
92
Reaction score
0
Location
Selah, Washington
sprhawk":1ij5ad95 said:
Because it's not cool to overshadow a ring of honor player with a need fill player that turned out to be better than expected

Lynch helped to get us thru a tough time but as far as RB's go, the truth is he is average.

As a fan I hope he has another good season but he is a 27 year old powerback in his 8th NFL season.

Its Turbin time.

Respectfully disagree! I do like Turbin too though!!
 

hawker84

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 10, 2012
Messages
5,909
Reaction score
637
Location
Tri Cities, WA
sprhawk,

please just stop now.. Alexander was a very good back, who benefited from one of the greatest left sides in seahawk history and arguably league history.. what lynch does on a weekly basis with the current line, is beyond spectacular... it's great to appreciate what shaun did for us, but let's not get carried away..

there's no way Alexander breaks those tackles and makes that run.. Give the man his just credit...
 

Chapow

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 11, 2010
Messages
6,130
Reaction score
2,159
sprhawk":i3i8g4vt said:
Because it's not cool to overshadow a ring of honor player with a need fill player that turned out to be better than expected

Lynch helped to get us thru a tough time but as far as RB's go, the truth is he is average.

As a fan I hope he has another good season but he is a 27 year old powerback in his 8th NFL season.

Its Turbin time.


What are you even talking about? Who is trying to overshadow anyone?

This thread is about if Marshawn has 3 more good years as a Seahawk, he could end up 2nd in rushing yards in team history.

2nd, you know, behind Alexander.

And good luck with your "Lynch is average" argument. I don't think you'd find many NFL coaches or players that agree with you.

I sure hope Turbin turns out as average as Lynch.
 

gspin2k1

New member
Joined
Feb 8, 2013
Messages
204
Reaction score
0
Agreed. Beastquake is the single best Seahawks memory I have.[/quote]

That run is memoriable only because Lynch seldom tears off big runs. It was an awesome moment but looking back it was missed tackles and horrible coverage that made that play, not Lynch.

SA used to tear off huge runs every week. Sorry you missed the show. There was nothing like seeing SA make a couple of cuts and break free for a long TD run.[/quote]

You do realize that pretty much all good offensive plays can be looked at as an outcome of poor defense and vice versa -_-. :roll:
 

sprhawk

New member
Joined
Apr 22, 2013
Messages
22
Reaction score
0
That Old arguement... How many years did he have that left side? He must have brought them with him from Bama.

Comparing SA's carreer stats Lynch is in his final season and needs 3,321 yards, 54 TDs this season to catch Shaun.

I appreciate that Lynch is in the here and now and I support him but to say he is anywhere near SA is silly imo.

Lynch doesn't have good vision or cutting ability. He is a good powerback but no Okoye.

They are completly differnt styles of backs but SA was one of the best of his style.
 

SouthSoundHawk

New member
Joined
Aug 20, 2012
Messages
2,262
Reaction score
0
Turbin will be ready to go when 'shawn is ready to call it quits, looking forward to seeing his progress during this time.


Also, I don't remember seeing any SA runs being mentioned as the greatest of all time. Just saying. Still, gotta give them both the respect they deserve.


I'll take an average RB that ranked in the top 5 NFL rushers last year, ALL DAY. Wish we could find more average players to fill some of these roster spots.
 

pcbball12

New member
Joined
Mar 28, 2011
Messages
736
Reaction score
0
sprhawk":7d5aldsf said:
That Old arguement... How many years did he have that left side? He must have brought them with him from Bama.

Comparing SA's carreer stats Lynch is in his final season and needs 3,321 yards, 54 TDs this season to catch Shaun.

I appreciate that Lynch is in the here and now and I support him but to say he is anywhere near SA is silly imo.

Lynch doesn't have good vision or cutting ability. He is a good powerback but no Okoye.

They are completly differnt styles of backs but SA was one of the best of his style.
You're right. Shaun was the absolute best at his style ( going down when someone breathed on him). With that joke aside (kinda) Shaun obviously was great for his span and he fit perfectly in the offense Holmgren wanted to run. But, to say Marshawn is average is a complete joke. He constantly breaks tackles and doesn't leave any yards on the field.
 

sprhawk

New member
Joined
Apr 22, 2013
Messages
22
Reaction score
0
pcbball12":2j0exgjq said:
You're right. Shaun was the absolute best at his style ( going down when someone breathed on him). With that joke aside (kinda) Shaun obviously was great for his span and he fit perfectly in the offense Holmgren wanted to run. But, to say Marshawn is average is a complete joke. He constantly breaks tackles and doesn't leave any yards on the field.

Statistically last year should have been, and was Lynch's best year. If he follows most RB's patterns we will see a sharp decline this year.

Take a look at Lynch's stats and tell me he will be remembered as anything other than an average back. Doesn't look like HOF numbers but I'm sure they will take in consideration that he didn't have a left side to get him there.
 

Hasselbeck

New member
Joined
May 2, 2009
Messages
11,397
Reaction score
4
ivotuk":1thrc529 said:
Marshawn is an uncommon physical freak whose body will not break down like average RBs.

He's already breaking down slowly, hence his back issues.

I love Marshawn, but any longer than 3 years playing the way he does would be very surprising. Running backs hit that "Age 30" wall and quickly deteriorate
 

sprhawk

New member
Joined
Apr 22, 2013
Messages
22
Reaction score
0
Hasselbeck":aog36rke said:
He's already breaking down slowly, hence his back issues.

I love Marshawn, but any longer than 3 years playing the way he does would be very surprising. Running backs hit that "Age 30" wall and quickly deteriorate

While the 30 wall has proven fatal, I think it may be more related to time served. Imagine 8 seasons in the NFL as a running back. The NFL isn't what it used to be but that is still a lot of hits.

I'll hand it to Lynch for recovering from injuries during his carreer. 2012 (last year) was the first season he actually played in all 16 games.

SA played in every game for 6 years. In 2006 he played thru injuries he shouldn't have which led to his last 2 seasons and the infamous "touch and drop" persona. Taking hits with broken bones can't be fun.
 

Zebulon Dak

Banned
Joined
Mar 4, 2007
Messages
24,551
Reaction score
1,417
sprhawk":25ratinj said:
That run is memoriable only because Lynch seldom tears off big runs. It was an awesome moment but looking back it was missed tackles and horrible coverage that made that play, not Lynch.

SA used to tear off huge runs every week. Sorry you missed the show. There was nothing like seeing SA make a couple of cuts and break free for a long TD run.

This is so stupid.
 

pcbball12

New member
Joined
Mar 28, 2011
Messages
736
Reaction score
0
sprhawk":3bezmxe4 said:
Hasselbeck":3bezmxe4 said:
He's already breaking down slowly, hence his back issues.

I love Marshawn, but any longer than 3 years playing the way he does would be very surprising. Running backs hit that "Age 30" wall and quickly deteriorate

While the 30 wall has proven fatal, I think it may be more related to time served. Imagine 8 seasons in the NFL as a running back. The NFL isn't what it used to be but that is still a lot of hits.

I'll hand it to Lynch for recovering from injuries during his carreer. 2012 (last year) was the first season he actually played in all 16 games.

SA played in every game for 6 years. In 2006 he played thru injuries he shouldn't have which led to his last 2 seasons and the infamous "touch and drop" persona. Taking hits with broken bones can't be fun.

Maybe if you look at him from a career standpoint he will be a little above average. But right now, the last two years, and probably next 2.......Marshawn is one of the top 5 running backs in the league. So for a span of 4+ years Marshawn will have been a top 5 running back in the league...hardly average. It is not much different than the span SA was a top RB in the league. SA just happened to rack up ridiculous numbers in a few seasons behind the best left side there probably ever was (and that is not even debatable....2 1st ballot HOF'ers).
 

hawker84

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 10, 2012
Messages
5,909
Reaction score
637
Location
Tri Cities, WA
sprhawk":1f26q8wb said:
Hasselbeck":1f26q8wb said:
He's already breaking down slowly, hence his back issues.

I love Marshawn, but any longer than 3 years playing the way he does would be very surprising. Running backs hit that "Age 30" wall and quickly deteriorate

While the 30 wall has proven fatal, I think it may be more related to time served. Imagine 8 seasons in the NFL as a running back. The NFL isn't what it used to be but that is still a lot of hits.

I'll hand it to Lynch for recovering from injuries during his carreer. 2012 (last year) was the first season he actually played in all 16 games.

SA played in every game for 6 years. In 2006 he played thru injuries he shouldn't have which led to his last 2 seasons and the infamous "touch and drop" persona. Taking hits with broken bones can't be fun.

you're more than entitled to your opinion,.. but most will disagree with you, and you're basically wasting your time trying to get them to your view... no one thinks Alexander is not a good back, but to say Lynch is average loses a lot of credibility IMO>.. as much as i appreciate what Shaun did for us, i'd take lynch in his prime over Alexander in his prime any day of the week...
 

Seahawk Sailor

Active member
Joined
Mar 3, 2007
Messages
22,963
Reaction score
1
Location
California via Negros Occidental, Philippines
I'm sorry, I don't get the Alexander hate. Lynch does only seldom tear off big runs. He's usually a smash-the-pile-forward-for-nine-yards kind of guy. It's what he does, and that kind of running just doesn't rack up the huge yardage games. The most yards per game he racked up all last year, even while "carrying the weight" because of Wilson's learning curve was 128. His career high for a game is 158, his rookie year. He had two straight seasons where he didn't break 100 yards. He's a great back, but he gets consistent, low-yardage carries based on his style.

I have the feeling many posters here hopped aboard in 2007 the way they talk about Alexander. His running style may be criticized for being "soft," but remember that awesome streak of games where he maintained at least one 10+ yard rush every single game? As I recall, that number is in the high sixties or low seventies and is an NFL record. He consistently had plays that broke long, and that was fun to watch. It's also the reason he has so many yards rushing.

I think it's a pretty steep bet Lynch ends up #2 all-time Seahawks rusher. That's a lot of yards. Last year was his best year by far at 1,580. He can do it, and I hope like hell he will, but it'll be tough.
 
Top