The Ringer's 2024 QB Rankings going into Week 1
Geno is ranked #10.
"There is no throw he doesn't think he can make, and he's usually
right."
"Geno Smith has developed into one of the most well-rounded quarterbacks in the NFL. Good luck finding a real weakness in his game."
"...but Smith's biggest strength is also his biggest weakness. His confidence in the pocket leads to bigger opportunities for the Seahawks offense... ...(b)ut it also leads to more sacks and potentially risky throws late in the down."
There's more in the link and I think the overall thing is interesting to read. They use a different style of QB ranking, wherein the try to rank each QB on individual attributes (Accuracy, Creativity, Pocket Presence, etc.) rather than just using stats and create a composite score with that. I think Geno's rank is pretty much where I have him, so no issues there, but disagree with some things on this list.
For example, there is no mention of the fact that Patrick Mahomes had a relative down year, Aaron Rodgers is ranked in the top 10 and Jordan Love isn't and I would do the opposite right now, Justin Herbert and Matt Stafford above Dak Prescott... they also don't rate Purdy or Tua in the top 10 at all--which I instinctively agree with but seeing the likes of Trevor Lawrence and Kyler Murray ahead of those two seems wrong.
It's well written though and they make a decent enough defense of some of the decisions I disagree with, so use it as food for thought.