FlyingGreg":1q4lnnfb said:
We earned the right to do whatever we want with the language.
Signed,
Victors of 1776 and 1812 and savers of your butts in WWI and WWII
First off, I'd agree with nategreat that there is a distinct difference between "next Tuesday" and "the next Tuesday." Roland's point rests solely on the definition of the word "next" without regard to common usage. People tend to think of weeks as whole units, and so the Tuesday of this week, regardless of whether it has passed or not, is considered "this Tuesday." When people say "next Tuesday," they are almost always referring to the Tuesday belonging to the next WEEK, not necessarily the Tuesday that comes up next. And even that formation tends to get fuzzier near the end of the week. If someone asks you on a Wednesday when your doctor's appointment is scheduled, you very likely might say "next Tuesday." If someone asks you the same thing on Saturday, you will probably just say, "Tuesday." Proximity matters.
It's an interesting topic, but one that I think Roland is being far, far too rigid on, as language is malleable and is changed by common usage (as much as that might irk him).
And the reason I quoted Greg here... I agree with most of the signature line, but wasn't 1812 pretty much just a situation where everyone said, "Hey, this is kind of pointless now. Wanna stop?"