Geno is mediocre at best. Borderline backup. A backup should win you 50% of their games. Thats Geno. Sayanora and Guadalajara Geno!! Go average 1.2 Td's a game somewhere else.
What? A backup should win you 50% of their games? That would make a backup the equivalent of an average starter. (Since, by definition, the 'average' starter is going to win 50% of games if every starter played every game).
There is no definitive way to measure this (since who's a 'starter' and who's not changes throughout the year), but the record for QBs who had 8 or less starts this year (which certainly includes a number of guys who were starters) is about 44%. Now, that might not seem like a big difference from 50%, but that's approximately a 7-10 season when played out.
---
On top of that, we've already established that Geno had bottom 10 pass blocking, bottom 10 defense in points allowed, and bottom 5 running game support. I decided to do a quick look at how other teams fared in similar situations over the past 4 years. (I picked 4 because 2020 was the earliest season that I could find ESPN pass block win rate numbers, which I used to rate pass blocking).
In those 4 seasons, only 4 total teams faired that poorly across all 3 categories. Us this year, Falcons and Texans in 2021, and the Jaguars in 2020. The only team to end with a winning record out of that group was the Seahawks. The average record for these teams is 5-12! And you think Geno should have delivered 10+? Seriously?