I’m callin it, Brock Purdy is him

[Maulbert]

I don't understand what the issues are with Brock.. other than he's a 49er.. Seems not to make mistakes, plays within himself..passes are accurate and doesn't seem to get rattled that said, I don't like him, he's a 9er.

He's a 49er. That's enough.

 

[SantaClaraHawk]

I don't understand what the issues are with Brock.. other than he's a 49er.. Seems not to make mistakes, plays within himself..passes are accurate and doesn't seem to get rattled that said, I don't like him, he's a 9er.

I like him even though he is a 49er.

 

[bileever]

I hate it that the 49ers got so lucky. But props to Shanahan for finding him, and then having the insight to play the guy. Shanahan is one lucky guy.

 

[Maulbert]

Brock Purdy IS him!!!!



By which I mean, Jimmy Garoppolo.

55/88, 762 yards, 3 TDs, 5 Ints with a 77.9 passer rating in the last 3 games.

 

[bigskydoc]

Shanahan found Purdy, but is going to ruin him.

 

[Fade]

Purdy G?

Imagine hitching your wagon to Brock Purdy! The Niners are boned.

 

[Chukarhawk]

Purdy G?

Imagine hitching your wagon to Brock Purdy! The Niners are boned.

I LOVE IT!!

 

[SonicHawk]

3 games in a row where Purdy has been bad. Doesn't mean he's bad, but he has been bad. He made me a believer earlier this year the way he was dottin' people up, but he's had some regression.

 

[evergreen]

I think it's pretty hard to be a QB in the NFL. If your's isn't awesome, there's not a bunch of new ones to trade into. We have Geno who on his best is a top ten but his floor is top 20. Just ask Trent Dilfer or Joe Flacco.

 

[94Smith]

Brock Purdy IS him!!!!



By which I mean, Jimmy Garoppolo.

55/88, 762 yards, 3 TDs, 5 Ints with a 77.9 passer rating in the last 3 games.

View attachment 61484

Almost the same as Geno Smith:

68/102 799 yards 4 TD/5INt and a 82.9 % rating. Plus a long history of suckage. Ill take the rookie thanks

 

[SoulfishHawk]

and that rookie contract, can't say I blame you

 

[Maulbert]

Almost the same as Geno Smith:

68/102 799 yards 4 TD/5INt and a 82.9 % rating. Plus a long history of suckage. Ill take the rookie thanks

No one was calling Geno Joe Montana. But keep up the false equivalencies, please. You sound like ScooterMagruder trying to call Dak elite.

 

[Marvin49]

No one was calling Geno Joe Montana. But keep up the false equivalencies, please. You sound like ScooterMagruder trying to call Dak elite.

People are WAY to quick to flip from "elite" to "he sucks".

Purdy is good. No question at all to me. Question is HOW good. Is this his ceiling? Will he become Jimmy G?

What was frustrating with Jimmy wasn't that he made mistakes. It was that he kept constantly making the SAME mistakes. He never learned.

Brock isn't Jimmy. First off, he is a FAR, FAR more accurate thrower, particularly down field. He's also MUCH less impacted by pressure.

The question is whether he learns from these mistakes or he does what Jimmy did and never learns the lesson.

 

[bigskydoc]

Jimmy also tended to make his mistakes at the worst possible times. It was uncanny.

 

[TwistedHusky]

Imagine this is why Deebo wanted what he wanted.
The 49ers are going to continue to lose until Deebo comes back.
Then magically, they are going to start winning and their rush attack will become one of the better ones again.

He's integral to their success. That means they don't succeed without him.
Its also likely the reason their QB looked so good and now looks so bad.

 

[Marvin49]

Jimmy also tended to make his mistakes at the worst possible times. It was uncanny.

No lies detected.

 

[Marvin49]

Imagine this is why Deebo wanted what he wanted.
The 49ers are going to continue to lose until Deebo comes back.
Then magically, they are going to start winning and their rush attack will become one of the better ones again.

He's integral to their success. That means they don't succeed without him.
Its also likely the reason their QB looked so good and now looks so bad.

Possible some truth there...

...but honestly I think it has more to do with Trent Williams being out. The O-Line isn't great...ESPECIALLY without Trent.

That's a big reason they can't run. Brock also went 3-0 without Deebo last year.

 

[Maulbert]

People are WAY to quick to flip from "elite" to "he sucks".

Purdy is good. No question at all to me. Question is HOW good. Is this his ceiling? Will he become Jimmy G?

What was frustrating with Jimmy wasn't that he made mistakes. It was that he kept constantly making the SAME mistakes. He never learned.

Brock isn't Jimmy. First off, he is a FAR, FAR more accurate thrower, particularly down field. He's also MUCH less impacted by pressure.

The question is whether he learns from these mistakes or he does what Jimmy did and never learns the lesson.

I never said Purdy was elite, I never said he sucks. I said he's a point guard who will go as far as the talent around him carries him, he will not carry a team himself.

Guess what? That's exactly what Jimmy Garoppolo is.

 

[Marvin49]

I never said Purdy was elite, I never said he sucks. I said he's a point guard who will go as far as the talent around him carries him, he will not carry a team himself.

Guess what? That's exactly what Jimmy Garoppolo is.

I know you didn't. That wasn't really directed at you...speaking more in generality.

 

[Maulbert]

I know you didn't. That wasn't really directed at you...speaking more in generality.

But you quoted me. If you aren't speaking directly to my comment, why quote me?