Will you trade John Schneider for two 1st and two 3rd?

toffee · May 5, 2026

SoulfishHawk said:
My boy Toff took it next level. Don't ever change

Next old-fashioned on me!

toffee · May 5, 2026

glenwo2 said:
It's toffee.

I can never tell whenever he's being sarcastic or not.

I am quite used to voicing unpopular opinions. A few that I can remember, I started threads to

Trade Russell Wilson in 2021.
Let Geno play when Wilson came back with his finger injury, 2021.
Critique Carroll for starting Wilson with his finger injury
Start Geno after Wilson was traded.
Trade Lockett in 2023 and 2024.
Winning the Super Bowl in the last off-season.
Our OL's coming of age in the last off-season, remember the Schneider line?

I earned by no-trade clause, LMAO.

Natethegreat · May 5, 2026

toffee said:
I am quite used to voicing unpopular opinions. A few that I can remember, I started threads to

Trade Russell Wilson in 2021.

Let Geno play when Wilson came back with his finger injury, 2021.

Critique Carroll for starting Wilson with his finger injury

Start Geno after Wilson was traded.

Trade Lockett in 2023 and 2024.

Winning the Super Bowl in the last off-season.

Our OL's coming of age in the last off-season, remember the Schneider line?

I earned by no-trade clause, LMAO.

You left out fire JS and keep Geno around along with multiple other really wrong takes last year. You spent all last off season campaigning against JS and now this dumb thread.

Atradees · May 6, 2026

GemCity said:
This just in: DEAL? offered two picks for @toffee .

What say you .netizens?

Dems just jokes toffee!

toffee said:
In February 2002, the Tampa Bay Buccaneers traded an unprecedented package of four draft picks (2002/2003 first-rounders, 2002/2004 second-rounders) and 8 millions.

John Schneider has been higher trade value than Gruden.

Yes. But when Gruden was traded he went to the Suoerbowl still. So it was worth it. Could John do that?

Optimus25 · May 6, 2026

MoldyPurpleMayo said:
A billionaire walks into a successful franchise where the GM has won 2 SB rings with two completely different sets of players on a team and 2 different head coaches and he trades him...

View attachment 79970

2 Firsts and 2 thirds is an incredible pot and you have to factor in that there are other talented GMs out there who would fall over themselves to get that kind of draft PLUS the current roster.

You guys sound like the ‘we can’t trade Russ’, ‘ we traded Geno now we’re finished’, ‘we got rid of Bobby now we’ll never win’ snails who don’t understand ‘sell high’.

MORGULON · May 6, 2026

Optimus25 said:
2 Firsts and 2 thirds is an incredible pot and you have to factor in that there are other talented GMs out there who would fall over themselves to get that kind of draft PLUS the current roster.

You guys sound like the ‘we can’t trade Russ’, ‘ we traded Geno now we’re finished’, ‘we got rid of Bobby now we’ll never win’ snails who don’t understand ‘sell high’.

But then you'd be forced to find a 2X SB winning GM to utilize the picks. JS MM obviously work well together .I'd take Schneider over anyone.

irfuben32 · May 6, 2026

Boycie said:
Pretty obvious that it was Pete holding us back and not JS. Answer is NO!

It has been a couple years and we haven't seen anything like a Pervy Harvin, Jimmy Graham, Jamal Adams trade. Starting to look like those were on Pete.

jeremiah · May 6, 2026

toffee said:
The incoming new ownership may want their own dude. With Schneider's stock at an all-time high, what can we get for him? I think two 1st and two 3rd would be the base, the floor. He is clearly more important than Russell Wilson with far more impact on any team's well-being, right?

I wouldn't trade him for 5 consecutive 1st round picks from different years. He delivers, he is THE best in the business right now.

jeremiah · May 6, 2026

irfuben32 said:
It has been a couple years and we haven't seen anything like a Pervy Harvin, Jimmy Graham, Jamal Adams trade. Starting to look like those were on Pete.

Should have kicked Harvin to the curb and kept Golden Tate around. Who in the -F- deserves the blame for that Cluster -F-?

toffee · May 6, 2026

Optimus25 said:
2 Firsts and 2 thirds is an incredible pot and you have to factor in that there are other talented GMs out there who would fall over themselves to get that kind of draft PLUS the current roster.

You guys sound like the ‘we can’t trade Russ’, ‘ we traded Geno now we’re finished’, ‘we got rid of Bobby now we’ll never win’ snails who don’t understand ‘sell high’.

Schneider's stock is in all the high, I think two each of 1st and 2nd plus some players sounded about right.

Rat · May 6, 2026

irfuben32 said:
It has been a couple years and we haven't seen anything like a Pervy Harvin, Jimmy Graham, Jamal Adams trade. Starting to look like those were on Pete.

So all the good picks and trades from until two years ago were on Pete also?

Or maybe Schneider learned from his own mistakes.

MoldyPurpleMayo · May 6, 2026

Optimus25 said:
2 Firsts and 2 thirds is an incredible pot and you have to factor in that there are other talented GMs out there who would fall over themselves to get that kind of draft PLUS the current roster.

You guys sound like the ‘we can’t trade Russ’, ‘ we traded Geno now we’re finished’, ‘we got rid of Bobby now we’ll never win’ snails who don’t understand ‘sell high’.

Sure, when you put it like that, it's an AMAZING idea to get those picks for our HoF GM to put it in the hands of someone unproven, what could POSSIBLY go wrong??

Difference between Russ, Geno, Bobby compared to Schneider is blatantly obvious and if you can't tell the difference then I don't even know what more I could tell you. Guess you're so tired of winning, you want to roll the dice on losing? It's like that episode of Family Guy when Peter could choose a boat and a mystery box. "Yeah I get it we have a SB caliber GM but the NEW GM could be great, even a SB caliber GM!"

CouchLogic · May 6, 2026

glenwo2 · May 7, 2026

CouchLogic said:
View attachment 80011

That's funny....if not also a bit frightening.

loafoftatupu · May 7, 2026

I can only speculate but if I had the money to buy the Seahawks I am fairly confident that I would not try to replace the GM that has had a fairly strong showing, especially in the last 4 years. Hard Pass x100

irfuben32 · May 7, 2026

Rat said:
So all the good picks and trades from until two years ago were on Pete also?

Or maybe Schneider learned from his own mistakes.

maybe, but the good stuff has continued and the terrible swing for the fences trades haven't. It might be to early to tell. We are riding a talent bubble that came from the Russell Wilson trade. Maybe on the backend of this when guys are on big contracts and we have a few injuries we might see it again.

Rat · May 8, 2026

irfuben32 said:
maybe, but the good stuff has continued and the terrible swing for the fences trades haven't. It might be to early to tell. We are riding a talent bubble that came from the Russell Wilson trade. Maybe on the backend of this when guys are on big contracts and we have a few injuries we might see it again.

Our last "swing for the fence" trade was years before Pete left.

Ozzy · May 8, 2026

Boycie said:
Pretty obvious that it was Pete holding us back and not JS. Answer is NO!

This x100. It was even much worse than I thought it was and I was on that train the last 3 years Pete was here.

Seahawker · May 8, 2026

Ozzy said:
This x100. It was even much worse than I thought it was and I was on that train the last 3 years Pete was here.

Will you trade John Schneider for two 1st and two 3rd?

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Tastes like TV static

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Moderator

Well-known member

Similar threads