Can you read NFL defenses? Probably not. But you are probably better at it than Milroe. Even so, his terrible ability to assess and react to defenses, his piss poor accuracy, and all the rest...aren't the main problem.
The problem is that he is a massive risk.
The stuff I was hearing about what was going on at Bama? Probably worse than anything I have ever heard about a QB in college, with the exception of someone doing SA/hard R, or the dogfighting thing.
You kept hearing about how the locker room was completely divided, with those supporting Milroe and pressuring others to do so, and the schism with those who resisted.
The odd thing is that it isn't clear Milroe is the one responsible for some of the terrible stuff going on off-field regarding this. But his camp was either involved, or HE was orchestrating what those people were doing. Either way, big risk. Big red flag.
Risks for upside don't make sense here. Even if you convert him into a RB, WR, or defensive player - you are still dealing with someone, maybe in Milroe himself - conducting himself in way that can destroy a team.
Is it just a rumor from Bama? Maybe. But I heard it from enough people over there to give it credence, ESPECIALLY because if true then it given Kalen a huge excuse. And frankly, the people at Bama are livid with Kalen. It isn't likely they all started supporting a rumor that defends him.
The downside here is bad. The upside is maybe moving him to another position. Is that worth it?