What's your outcome if Geno replaced Hurts in Philly?

[OrangeGravy]

How much better or worse or not at all, would Philly's offense be with Geno vs Hurtz?

 

[Rat]

I don't think Hurts has been super impressive this season, so probably about the same.

They arent in the Super Bowl two years ago with that switch though. And we definitely make the playoffs last year with Hurts, while making a deeper run the year prior.

 

[keasley45]

Its like Murph said, i almost want Geno to leave and take some other team to a championship. If he was on a team with a solid D, running game and was protected at least at a middle of the pack level he'd be dangerous.

 

[evergreen]

Put him on the Stealers

 

[projectorfreak]

Put him on the Stealers

That would probably do it for him
It'd a killer for rw to have geno eclipse him but russ still got a moon ball from hell though

 

[SoulfishHawk]

I'd much rather have Hurts than Geno. I said what I said

 

[pittpnthrs]

Not sure how any QB would fair in Philly with the injuries and talent level they have/had at the WR positions. Let's face it, without Brown they are pretty much helpless most of the times.

 

[Seahawks fan]

Significantly better.. With that run game Geno would cut up defenses with play-action all day..

 

[chris98251]

Tampering Charges and fines by the NFL.

 

[toffee]

The better way to phrase the question could be: "Would you trade Geno for Hurts?" I suspect most 12s on dot net would vote yes.

To most on dot net, Geno lost or never won over their hearts and minds, to those folks, Geno is and will always be that glorified backup. When Geno had a really good game, those folks would pinch their noses and praise, when Geno struggled, celebration time with champagnes.

I liken that to stepmom syndrome, lol, she will never be as good as your mom and you will her to fail.

 

[GetNjigbaWithIt]

The better way to phrase the question could be: "Would you trade Geno for Hurts?" I suspect most 12s on dot net would vote yes.

To most on dot net, Geno lost or never won over their hearts and minds, to those folks, Geno is and will always be that glorified backup. When Geno had a really good game, those folks would pinch their noses and praise, when Geno struggled, celebration time with champagnes.

I liken that to stepmom syndrome, lol, she will never be as good as your mom and you will her to fail.

You're not my mom, Gina!

 

[toffee]

You're not my mom, Gina!

View attachment 68230

Now I can't unseen that.

 

[Ozzy]

Worse. Hurts is a good QB and the threat of him running helps Barkley and they lose their short yardage advantage.

 

[Chukarhawk]

The better way to phrase the question could be: "Would you trade Geno for Hurts?" I suspect most 12s on dot net would vote yes.

To most on dot net, Geno lost or never won over their hearts and minds, to those folks, Geno is and will always be that glorified backup. When Geno had a really good game, those folks would pinch their noses and praise, when Geno struggled, celebration time with champagnes.

I liken that to stepmom syndrome, lol, she will never be as good as your mom and you will her to fail.

Wanting Geno to fail is crazy. Never been a big Hurts guy, BUT he would probably outperform Geno with this ghastly 0line. Toss up for me and Geno is way cheaper. Leaning Mr. middle of the road Geno.

 

[toffee]

Worse. Hurts is a good QB and the threat of him running helps Barkley and they lose their short yardage advantage.

If Hurts is better, how about our 2nd round pick and Geno for Hurts?

 

[Appyhawk]

Hurts would teach our guys the toosh push and as a result we would have more rushing TDs, AND at least one more 4th down conversion.
Philly might have a few more deep shot completions than they do but would be giving up a much more productive ground game from the QB position.
The thing about Geno running for us is I worry about him surviving the punishment.

 

[toffee]

Hurts would teach our guys the toosh push and as a result we would have more rushing TDs, AND at least one more 4th down conversion.
Philly might have a few more deep shot completions than they do but would be giving up a much more productive ground game from the QB position.
The thing about Geno running for us is I worry about him surviving the punishment.

Geno and our first for Hurts and their 2 second?

 

[Ozzy]

they aren’t that close. Hurts is much better. First half of 22 Geno was better. Every thing since then is Hurts by quite a bit.

 

[CouchLogic]

Slow week? Why waste timme thinking about this? We going to do this for every team or what?

I hate fantasy football/madden GM BS [lol].

 

[OrangeGravy]

Slow week? Why waste timme thinking about this? We going to do this for every team or what?

I hate fantasy football/madden GM BS [lol].

It's a good way to get people to reveal themselves