Some of us do have a few arguments regarding why Geno Smith may not be the future franchise QB in the NFL with the Seahawks, but these points are context-dependent and could evolve based on his performance over this season. Hence, the first half of the Bronco's game in week 1 vs Geno in the Steeler's game in week 2. Here are some of the common concerns raised about him:
1. Inconsistency
One of the biggest criticisms of Geno Smith has been his inconsistency. While he has shown flashes of solid play, his performance can vary dramatically from game to game. In the NFL, consistency is crucial for a starting quarterback, especially when leading a team over the course of a season.
2. Turnovers
In his earlier career, Geno struggled with turnovers. His decision-making at times led to costly interceptions or fumbles, and turnover-prone QBs tend to lose games. The question now is do we still view him as a reliable or a risky starter?
3. Limited Ceiling
One can argue that Geno Smith may have reached his ceiling as a quarterback. While capable, can you say with complete confidence that he may be able to possess the elite-level talent to carry a team deep into the playoffs or to compete at the highest level consistently, which is often expected from starting QB's.
4. Lack of Experience as a Long-Term Starter
Although he’s had stretches as a starter, Geno spent much of his career as a backup. His lack of experience leading a team for multiple seasons raises questions about whether he can maintain success or handle the pressure that comes with a starting role.
5. Competition in the NFL
With many talented quarterbacks entering the league each year, there’s a constant influx of younger, more dynamic players, which I believe for us is Howell. Often teams might prefer a younger QB with a higher upside, relegating Geno to a backup or transitional role. Carolina, as they seem to be experiencing with their QB (cough cough Bryce), is not always a guarantee in the NFL, but what is to be perfectly honest. This may be where the Seahawk's front office stands at this moment in time, but holding their cards close to the vest.
6. Past Injuries
Though not a major concern recently, perhaps one minor injury I believe around the preseason this year, Geno has dealt with injuries in the past. His durability over a full season is another potential issue for Seattle in evaluating his long-term viability as a starter.
That said, Geno Smith is having a resurgence with our team, showing improved decision-making and accuracy, so some of these concerns may be outdated depending on his more recent performances. Still, these points reflect why certain some of us as fans, being critics, might argue against him as a long-term starting option. It's also possible that with the current new regime, they are better suited in hiding any flaws that Geno may possess as a QB, where previous coaching staff left him exposed. Only time will tell.
