Hawker8989
Member
- Joined
- Jan 6, 2017
- Messages
- 133
- Reaction score
- 3
Simple question: Who was the better Seahawks coach?
Honestly, I'm having a tough time figuring it out.
Honestly, I'm having a tough time figuring it out.
seahawkfreak":2ey4goif said:Sorry, Pete got us a Bowl, no other questions can be asked.
Hawker8989":9dlm6lqn said:seahawkfreak":9dlm6lqn said:Sorry, Pete got us a Bowl, no other questions can be asked.
Well when I look at the talent both coaches had, it's not an outlandish question. Mike didn't have the better QB ( Matt was damm good though). Didn't have the offense.
Hawker8989":2erd1cmw said:seahawkfreak":2erd1cmw said:Sorry, Pete got us a Bowl, no other questions can be asked.
Well when I look at the talent both coaches had, it's not an outlandish question. Mike didn't have the better QB ( Matt was damm good though). Didn't have the offense.
Fade":rd5wd93l said:Give Mike Holmgren the Seahawks rosters of '12-'16 and he wins more than 1 superbowl guaranteed.
Fade":1s9bw5lk said:Give Mike Holmgren the Seahawks rosters of '12-'16 and he wins more than 1 superbowl guaranteed.
Nothinbutm":24dsn6wq said:Fade":24dsn6wq said:Give Mike Holmgren the Seahawks rosters of '12-'16 and he wins more than 1 superbowl guaranteed.
I'm inclined to agree with this.
Ad Hawk":7wo4pv38 said:Nothinbutm":7wo4pv38 said:Fade":7wo4pv38 said:Give Mike Holmgren the Seahawks rosters of '12-'16 and he wins more than 1 superbowl guaranteed.
I'm inclined to agree with this.
Maybe, but Mike Holmgren never would have created those rosters in the first place. His philosophy is completely different.
Fade":1lflvcqs said:Ad Hawk":1lflvcqs said:Nothinbutm":1lflvcqs said:Fade":1lflvcqs said:Give Mike Holmgren the Seahawks rosters of '12-'16 and he wins more than 1 superbowl guaranteed.
I'm inclined to agree with this.
Maybe, but Mike Holmgren never would have created those rosters in the first place. His philosophy is completely different.
So Holmy ships out Kam, Sherm, & ET. KJ & Bobby get jettisoned, etc. I don't thinks so.
The problem Holmy had was he couldn't build a defense.
Plop Holmgren down on the '12 Seahawks the defense is already built. He just has to worry about developing a rookie QB in RW. Which would have gone fantastically imo, because that is what Holmgren's expertise was.
The head scratching decisions of trading for Harvin, trading away Unger, ect. Go away too, as we all know Holmgren was very conventional. He wouldn't do weird things like starting Drew Nowak at Center. Or go crazy young across the entire O-Line.
Sure over time the defense would have eroded at a quicker pace with Carroll no longer at the helm, but on the flip side the offense would've gotten better & better. RW would have a couple MVPs and the team would have more Superbowls.
Holmgren wins at least 2 minimum, very confident he wins 3.
Holmgren won with Ruskell & Whitsitt as his GM. Let's see Pete Carroll do that.
Schneider bodies both of those losers.
Holmgren > Pete Carroll.
Ad Hawk":2dc2crqs said:You misread me. I said he never would have created those rosters in the first place.
If he inherited them? Well, I have my doubts about any coach willingly leaving with that roster. But say Pete died and Holmgren took over... it's hard to know, but he would never have stood for our O-line and running game, so he may have gotten rid of some D in order to get some O.