SoulfishHawk
Well-known member
John, step away from the keyboard. Let it go man. You're just gonna' give yourself high BP.
Meh
Meh
John63":3n3fyr42 said:Yards alone do not make a QB elite.
Wilson in 2013 accounted for 3896 yards(run and pass), 27 TDS, and a 101 passer rating. He was top 10 in TDS, pass rating, YPA, and he did that while only being 22nd in attempts. that is Elite. Also, he had 4 4th qtr OT comeback wins also top 5 in the league. an avg QB could not do that.
Also, we had a top 3 defense and run game and that run game was only top 3 because of Wilson who was our 2nd leading rusher.
Now as to your vision that is great but again you need a top run game, a top defense, and you still need a QB that can make magic. If it was as easy as you think every team would be able to do it but yet very few have done it with a QB who is not in the upper echelon. We had a top defense and run game in 2011 and were 7-9. When you play the type of game you want to play you have a low margin for error and as I showed often need a QB that can make magic.
Three words:olyfan63":1rfj1t30 said:John63":1rfj1t30 said:Yards alone do not make a QB elite.
Wilson in 2013 accounted for 3896 yards(run and pass), 27 TDS, and a 101 passer rating. He was top 10 in TDS, pass rating, YPA, and he did that while only being 22nd in attempts. that is Elite. Also, he had 4 4th qtr OT comeback wins also top 5 in the league. an avg QB could not do that.
Also, we had a top 3 defense and run game and that run game was only top 3 because of Wilson who was our 2nd leading rusher.
Now as to your vision that is great but again you need a top run game, a top defense, and you still need a QB that can make magic. If it was as easy as you think every team would be able to do it but yet very few have done it with a QB who is not in the upper echelon. We had a top defense and run game in 2011 and were 7-9. When you play the type of game you want to play you have a low margin for error and as I showed often need a QB that can make magic.
Wilson was a very good game manager and situational passer in 2013. Opposing defenses hadn't really figured out how to defend him and the read option with the threat of Lynch. Helping Wilson's comeback stats in 2013 was the Hawks' #1 ranked defense. Comebacks work way better when your offense scores and your defense holds the other team is held scoreless.
In 2014 (2015 SB49) we learned the truth about Russell Wilson and his inability to read certain types of defenses. It happened on the biggest stage at the worst possible moment. The pick by Malcolm Butler. All Russell could do in that situation was "trust the playcall". It coulda, shoulda been good enough Blame Bevell for the predictable offense that NE easily read thanks to Brandon Browner. The truth is that Russell wasn't good enough to overcome Bevell's schitty play call in that moment, by reading the Pats defense and knowing where to go with the ball. Maybe he was "too short" to see over the line and see Butler lurking? The horrible pick vs. the Rams in last year's Wildcard game was another moment of "the truth" about Russell. However, Fail Mary is also the truth about Russell (in a good way). So was the TD pass to Sidney Rice to beat Brady and the Patriots. Overall, the cold hard truth is that Russell isn't good enough to carry the team in a playoff game with his passing, not vs. a really good D. That's OK though, few QBs are. Give him a great D and an ass-whupping running game, and he's shown he can win a Super Bowl. Russell also needs an OC who can protect him with a good game plan that doesn't ask him to do things he is not very good at.
olyfan63":1w65wyxy said:John63":1w65wyxy said:Yards alone do not make a QB elite.
Wilson in 2013 accounted for 3896 yards(run and pass), 27 TDS, and a 101 passer rating. He was top 10 in TDS, pass rating, YPA, and he did that while only being 22nd in attempts. that is Elite. Also, he had 4 4th qtr OT comeback wins also top 5 in the league. an avg QB could not do that.
Also, we had a top 3 defense and run game and that run game was only top 3 because of Wilson who was our 2nd leading rusher.
Now as to your vision that is great but again you need a top run game, a top defense, and you still need a QB that can make magic. If it was as easy as you think every team would be able to do it but yet very few have done it with a QB who is not in the upper echelon. We had a top defense and run game in 2011 and were 7-9. When you play the type of game you want to play you have a low margin for error and as I showed often need a QB that can make magic.
Wilson was a very good game manager and situational passer in 2013. Opposing defenses hadn't really figured out how to defend him and the read option with the threat of Lynch. Helping Wilson's comeback stats in 2013 was the Hawks' #1 ranked defense. Comebacks work way better when your offense scores and your defense holds the other team is held scoreless.
In 2014 (2015 SB49) we learned the truth about Russell Wilson and his inability to read certain types of defenses. It happened on the biggest stage at the worst possible moment. The pick by Malcolm Butler. All Russell could do in that situation was "trust the playcall". It coulda, shoulda been good enough Blame Bevell for the predictable offense that NE easily read thanks to Brandon Browner. The truth is that Russell wasn't good enough to overcome Bevell's schitty play call in that moment, by reading the Pats defense and knowing where to go with the ball. Maybe he was "too short" to see over the line and see Butler lurking? The horrible pick vs. the Rams in last year's Wildcard game was another moment of "the truth" about Russell. However, Fail Mary is also the truth about Russell (in a good way). So was the TD pass to Sidney Rice to beat Brady and the Patriots. Overall, the cold hard truth is that Russell isn't good enough to carry the team in a playoff game with his passing, not vs. a really good D. That's OK though, few QBs are. Give him a great D and an ass-whupping running game, and he's shown he can win a Super Bowl. Russell also needs an OC who can protect him with a good game plan that doesn't ask him to do things he is not very good at.
SoulfishHawk":39hb54xw said:John, step away from the keyboard. Let it go man. You're just gonna' give yourself high BP.
Meh