Optimus25":oza4kvbt said:
But see, i don't always blame Bevell specifically for SELECTION, but a coach's responsibility rarely ends there. How many times was this play practiced?. How many times in practice was Jimmy as open out of his break as he was here?. Proper coaching would give russ perspective as to who is the primary read in what situation. As I've alluded to in previous posts, kearse should not be a target in these compressed field, man coverage situations. I just almost never see him win the matchup. Even when he gets the space in a bang bang play vs man, i think of the nfccg and balls flying off his hands for picks. It's just not his forte, so if Bevell coached JFG as the read and russ didn't follow thru, my bad. I can only assume it's not coached properly tho, especially since russ basically doesn't acknowledge Jimmy on the field.
You can coach a guy in the film room and practice field all you want, but at some point, Brandon Weeden isn't Tony Romo, Matt Flynn isn't Aaron Rodgers and Mike Vick isn't Ben Roethlisberger.
All I'm saying with that is that, in today's NFL, the OC doesn't have his hand up the QB's rear controlling everything he does. This is not the Mike Holmgren plug-and-play era of QBs anymore. If it were, the backups mentioned above would make the same decisions that their starting counterparts make. But they don't. Eventually, the QB's own ability to make good decisions, to independently diagnose defenses, and to make all the throws wins out over everything else. Can you make plays with what you're given? Stars do. Flame outs don't. Even within the same systems, we see wild variance. That's why $20M/year is the asking price for guys who can get it done.