ESPN article on LJ Collier's breakout year

bileever

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 16, 2022
Messages
1,996
Reaction score
2,720
Interesting article by Josh Weinfuss at ESPN about LJ Collier and his long journey to becoming a productive player:


Collier hated playing in Seattle and he doesn't mention anyone by name, but he says that there were coaches who didn't want him there and that "dudes got weird." He doesn't say who he means by "dudes," if it's other players or coaches. He says Seattle "wasn't my type of vibe, bro."
 

olyfan63

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 17, 2012
Messages
6,167
Reaction score
2,276
Reading the thread title, I thought maybe this was an early April Fool's joke?
As far as I knew, LJ's only breakout was as somebody's avatar on this board, failing to sack Kyler Murray but drawing a holding call in the end zone and a safety.
 

OneLofaTatupu

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 4, 2007
Messages
4,294
Reaction score
2,500
Location
Seattle, WA
Reading the thread title, I thought maybe this was an early April Fool's joke?
As far as I knew, LJ's only breakout was as somebody's avatar on this board, failing to sack Kyler Murray but drawing a holding call in the end zone and a safety.
It was juxtaposed with DJ Dallas break out year
 

toffee

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 9, 2016
Messages
13,384
Reaction score
9,109
Location
SoCal Desert
I was quite touched by his story, he could have given up after his injury with the Cardinals, most probably would have. He came, strongish, to show that if nothing else, he is a legit NFL player.

Good job Colliers, keep up the good work. I always put him in the same group as Penny, but he is not, he wanted it more, and strong enough go stay wanting it more. He rewarded me for creating threads about his achievements. Maybe he read my thread and got motivated. can I get a cut LJ of your new contract? lol.
 

Atradees

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 4, 2010
Messages
4,129
Reaction score
346
Location
Ich tu dir weh
Colliers retirement payment will be more than most of us make in a year...for a month. He was a wasted pick. Another head scratcher. Likely he didn't fit and in a corporation you endanger others around you with poor performance.
 

keasley45

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 4, 2010
Messages
5,008
Reaction score
9,106
Location
Cockeysville, Md
I was quite touched by his story, he could have given up after his injury with the Cardinals, most probably would have. He came, strongish, to show that if nothing else, he is a legit NFL player.

Good job Colliers, keep up the good work. I always put him in the same group as Penny, but he is not, he wanted it more, and strong enough go stay wanting it more. He rewarded me for creating threads about his achievements. Maybe he read my thread and got motivated. can I get a cut LJ of your new contract? lol.
It can absolutely happen that a person isn't a great fit for one organization, underachieves, is fired, then lands somewhere else where he connects better and flourishes under better leadership. Happens all the time.

And outside of that, its not like we presented him with a great group of leaders to work under. Ken Norton (Fired. Horrible defenses under his leadership). Clint Hurtt (Fired. Even worse defenses under is leadership). Pete (Fired, in large part for not assembling a better group of coordinators or holding them to account). So is it so hard to believe a player who says he struggled to find a footing when the guys leading you cant keep their jobs- and oh, BTW 31 other teams agree they also arent qualified to lead a defense.

Its more a reach IMO to think that the leadership on defense while he was here, although being horrible at actually assembling and leading a defense, was GREAT at mentoring and getting the most from their players than it is to call Collier out as making excuses for poor play during his time in Seattle. He may not be an All-pro or even pro-bowler, but you don't have to be either of those to be a player who contributes positively to his team - something he is doing now but couldn't sniff while he was here.
 

toffee

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 9, 2016
Messages
13,384
Reaction score
9,109
Location
SoCal Desert
It can absolutely happen that a person isn't a great fit for one organization, underachieves, is fired, then lands somewhere else where he connects better and flourishes under better leadership. Happens all the time.

And outside of that, its not like we presented him with a great group of leaders to work under. Ken Norton (Fired. Horrible defenses under his leadership). Clint Hurtt (Fired. Even worse defenses under is leadership). Pete (Fired, in large part for not assembling a better group of coordinators or holding them to account). So is it so hard to believe a player who says he struggled to find a footing when the guys leading you cant keep their jobs- and oh, BTW 31 other teams agree they also arent qualified to lead a defense.

Its more a reach IMO to think that the leadership on defense while he was here, although being horrible at actually assembling and leading a defense, was GREAT at mentoring and getting the most from their players than it is to call Collier out as making excuses for poor play during his time in Seattle. He may not be an All-pro or even pro-bowler, but you don't have to be either of those to be a player who contributes positively to his team - something he is doing now but couldn't sniff while he was here.
Interesting that we often see things the same way.
 

HawkRiderFan

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 19, 2011
Messages
2,243
Reaction score
1,187
When he says "coaches who didn't want him there" I hope he's not referring to Pete cause that would mean JS was the one who wanted him.
 

toffee

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 9, 2016
Messages
13,384
Reaction score
9,109
Location
SoCal Desert
When he says "coaches who didn't want him there" I hope he's not referring to Pete cause that would mean JS was the one who wanted him.
We will never know. From the press:

Schneider said:

Collier has physical talents, to be sure. As Schneider described seeing Collier at the Senior Bowl, "Being on the field at the Senior Bowl was really a cool thing to see, because he's got those heavy hands, he jumps off the ball, he's got snap anticipation." But the Seahawks also liked Collier for some of his intangibles. Collier didn't get a ton of recruiting interest as a small-school prospect out of tiny Munday, Texas—he graduated in a class of 25 seniors—then during his freshman year at TCU, his mother, Ruby, died after a battle with cancer.​
As Schneider put it, "He's just our kind of guy, that's the best way to describe it."​
Carroll also said:

"He's going to play five-technique (end) for us, and he's very flexible and he can move around," Carroll said. "The name I saw on TV—he's a lot like Michael Bennett. He has the versatility and the style and the penetration ability. He's really slippery, terrific pass-rush makeup. So we're going to fit him right into the scheme in that regard. We think it's going to work out great. You could see early on that he had that kind of stuff to him. He's real long, really good length, and he's got a really nice pass-rush bag of tricks. He's got all the stuff. So we think we've really got something special. And I fell in love with the fact that he had a big chip on his shoulder and he wanted to prove it and all that. He'll really fit in."​
 

Grand Strand Hawk Fan

Active member
Joined
Jul 25, 2023
Messages
114
Reaction score
119
Location
Conway, SC
Collier was a day 3 pick on many teams boards. John Schneider learned a very valuable lesson about drafting for only need in the 1st rd....we hope.
 

Spin Doctor

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 8, 2009
Messages
5,608
Reaction score
2,842
LJ Collier didn’t breakout… 3.5 sacks, low tackle count. Checked PFF just for the laughs, he is rated super low there too.

LJ Collier doing the bare minimum isn’t “breaking out”.
 

keasley45

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 4, 2010
Messages
5,008
Reaction score
9,106
Location
Cockeysville, Md
We will never know. From the press:

Schneider said:

Collier has physical talents, to be sure. As Schneider described seeing Collier at the Senior Bowl, "Being on the field at the Senior Bowl was really a cool thing to see, because he's got those heavy hands, he jumps off the ball, he's got snap anticipation." But the Seahawks also liked Collier for some of his intangibles. Collier didn't get a ton of recruiting interest as a small-school prospect out of tiny Munday, Texas—he graduated in a class of 25 seniors—then during his freshman year at TCU, his mother, Ruby, died after a battle with cancer.​
As Schneider put it, "He's just our kind of guy, that's the best way to describe it."​
Carroll also said:

"He's going to play five-technique (end) for us, and he's very flexible and he can move around," Carroll said. "The name I saw on TV—he's a lot like Michael Bennett. He has the versatility and the style and the penetration ability. He's really slippery, terrific pass-rush makeup. So we're going to fit him right into the scheme in that regard. We think it's going to work out great. You could see early on that he had that kind of stuff to him. He's real long, really good length, and he's got a really nice pass-rush bag of tricks. He's got all the stuff. So we think we've really got something special. And I fell in love with the fact that he had a big chip on his shoulder and he wanted to prove it and all that. He'll really fit in."​

Problem with the Pete era Hawks (and dont know how much of this was John or disconnect between John and Pete) but there were quite a few players who were brought in with one skillset and then made to play another position or technique. And the more you look back and see the occasional friction in disagreement between the players that John wanted and drafted and the way Pete wanted to use them, the more stories like Collier's makes sense, and the more believable it is when a player says thigs like 'i didnt feel like i was wanted'. Well, when the GM really wants a guy and that guy lands on the team, but the coach wasnt high on him, and wants to force him into the role HE wants him for, there's a conflict there within the leadership structure that can result in a player being caught in the middle and feeling EXACTLY the way Collier did.
 

Latest posts

Top