That was a fumble..

[Seahawks fan]

These refs are ,, That's was a fumble not a incomplete pass...

 

[Atradees]

Clearly big cat knocked it out before going forward

 

[Seahawks fan]

Again these refs are Harrison Jr is being treated like he's his daddy... That was offensive pass interference on him vs Riq....

 

[irfuben32]

I disagree, ball went forward because hand was moving forward

 

[Seahawks fan]

I disagree, ball went forward because hand was moving forward

Ball can go forward as long as the hand is empty, which the hand was empty that means it was a fumble...

 

[irfuben32]

Ball can go forward as long as the hand is empty, which the hand was empty that means it was a fumble...

that doesn't make any sense

the ball flew forward through the air because the hand was moving forward with the ball in it.

 

[Seahawks fan]

that doesn't make any sense

the ball flew forward through the air because the hand was moving forward with the ball in it.

No the ball can go forward and it still be a fumble it's called the empty hand and is a real rule, you should look it up...

 

[Seahawks fan]

that doesn't make any sense

the ball flew forward through the air because the hand was moving forward with the ball in it.

The act of a defender hitting the arm of the QB creats a whip action which makes the ball go forward even though the QB's arm never moved forward....

 

[irfuben32]

The act of a defender hitting the arm of the QB creats a whip action which makes the ball go forward even though the QB's arm never moved forward....

go outside with a ball and have your buddy chop your arm

see if they can do it hard enough so the whip action makes the ball fly ten yards

 

[rigelian]

I don't think it was a fumble because Murray had the ball in his hand moving forward for a split second, however, I agree that a player can push the ball forward even though he losses the grasp of the ball first.

 

[keasley45]

that doesn't make any sense

the ball flew forward through the air because the hand was moving forward with the ball in it.

If you push the ball forward but dont have control of it, its a fumble and thats what heppened. The ball was dislodge from his grip at the top of his motion. When his hand went forward after being hit, it was AT is hand. Not IN it.

 

[keasley45]

go outside with a ball and have your buddy chop your arm

see if they can do it hard enough so the whip action makes the ball fly ten yards

There are too many examples in the NFL of that having happened and been called a fumble to even count.

 

[Followthelegion]

Sorry this one definitely wasn’t a fumble. Hand moving forward with control is an incomplete pass.

I had a bigger issue with the non catch fumble when WR took 2 steps and turned up field while dragging one foot. Once called a fumble on the field it should have stayed a fumble. What a hit too.

 

[CalgaryFan05]

These refs are ,, That's was a fumble not a incomplete pass...

It was REALLY ******* close.

 

[SoulfishHawk]

Happened right below us and it was crazy close. At the stadium it did look like his arm was moving just barely. The one thing I'll say was that it was nice to see the refs actually let the play finish instead of the old whistle too early crap. I sent a few messages to friends watching tv and I'd say more than not said it was barely moving forward. Damn. Get that and take away the ridiculously bone headed throw by Geno in the end zone and this game might not be close. Arizona's defense is def. tough.

 

[Seahawks fan]

It was REALLY ******* close.

I know, But it was ruled a fumble then they overturned it, I feel there wasn't enough evidence to justify the call change...

 

[SoulfishHawk]

Looking forward to watching the replay.

 

[CalgaryFan05]

I know, But it was ruled a fumble then they overturned it, I feel there wasn't enough evidence to justify the call change...

You make a point.

 

[SoulfishHawk]

If that was the Niners or Rams, they would have awarded them 10 points and 4 draft picks........for one touchdown.

 

[SweepSanFran]

Not going to debate whether it was a fumble or not, but definitely not enough to change the call on the field. Have seen so many calls on the field not changed that should have been and their excuse is not enough to change the call.