Has anyone seen this?

[Torc]

Yeah, Geno Smith is clearly on par with one of the best QB's of all time. Got it.
All Mahomes does is win, over and and over and over again. Geno isn't in the same stratosphere as Mahomes. Dear God.........

I didn't say he was. Mahomes also has something that Geno doesn't. Two things, actually. An offensive line, and one of the best defenses in the league.

We can look at lot of places for what is ailing the Seahawks. Geno isn't in the top 10 of those reasons.

 

[SoulfishHawk]

Talent. Killer instinct. Being one of the best of all time. Clutch. Leader. Beast.

 

[PhxPhin]

Just because you can make a YouTube video doesn't mean you actually have something to say..........

 

[flv2]

The one thing about DK I think we can all appreciate is he wants to win, and win badly...

 

[RiverDog]

I didn't say he was. Mahomes also has something that Geno doesn't. Two things, actually. An offensive line, and one of the best defenses in the league.

We can look at lot of places for what is ailing the Seahawks. Geno isn't in the top 10 of those reasons.

I agree with this. Although he's not Mahomes, Jackson, or Allen, Geno is not the root cause of our woes. He doesn't win games, but he's not losing them for us, either.

However, I disagree that the Chiefs have "one of the best defenses in the league." They currently rank 22nd in total yards and 18th in points allowed.

 

[SoulfishHawk]

As far as DK goes, it's interesting that it gets glossed over that he had a long TD called back, another under throw that was w/out a doubt going to be a TD, and was a toe away from having another.
IF that was a different receiver, we likely would be hearing about it all week, imo.

 

[cymatica]

As far as DK goes, it's interesting that it gets glossed over that he had a long TD called back, another under throw that was w/out a doubt going to be a TD, and was a toe away from having another.
IF that was a different receiver, we likely would be hearing about it all week, imo.

No one is glossing over a missed TD and on that toe tap he had plenty of room to get his feet in. Watch the way he bends his legs in the air, like he's doing his best MJ impression, it's a weird habit and he does it all the time and if you watch that play that is exactly why his foot touched the line.

 

[TheLegendOfBoom]

Put DK at linebacker as well!

He gets angry at the offense, let him knock a few heads off on defense and get some of that over aggression out!

He’ll be level headed again!

 

[Maelstrom787]

Yeah, Geno Smith is clearly on par with one of the best QB's of all time. Got it.
All Mahomes does is win, over and and over and over again. Geno isn't in the same stratosphere as Mahomes. Dear God.........

If you want people to stop bringing up Mahomes, you should stop blaming Geno for stats you see as unacceptably poor when Mahomes has the same stats.

Pretty simple really

 

[SoulfishHawk]

You see it how you want to and make excuses for him. I'll see it how I want to.
I find it entertaining when people compare them.

 

[cymatica]

But all I read here is that DK… fumbles too much, can’t high point, runs lazy routes, isn’t physical enough, takes too many penalties and is a “head case”. How does all that translate to being worth more than Adams?

The twisted logic doesn’t seem to jibe. He is no good for us but give us a first rounder…

You're taking different things different people are saying, combining them, and then acting as if everyone criticizing him are being illogical. Haven't heard one single person who brings up those issues claiming he's worth that much.

 

[cymatica]

You see it how you want to and make excuses for him. I'll see it how I want to.
I find it entertaining when people compare them.

No one is comparing them, Mahomes stats were brought up to make a point

 

[SoulfishHawk]

Nah, people compare them often. Call it what you want. Geno has 50 plus more throws than any QB in the league......"He's leading the league in passing yards!!"
blah blah blah

 

[Maelstrom787]

Nah, people compare them often. Call it what you want. Geno has 50 plus more throws than any QB in the league......"He's leading the league in passing yards!!"
blah blah blah

People compare their stats in response to stat-based criticism of Geno.

Any implications that Geno's stats are indicative of a lack of talent or make winning impossible... welp, Patrick Mahomes on paper looks about exactly the same right now in terms of overall efficiency.

Also, Geno leads by 27 throws (Dak is second).

 

[SoulfishHawk]

Agree to disagree on Geno. I'm done talking about this subject. You're not gonna' budge, and I'm not gonna' budge. Geno isn't on the same planet as Patrick f'ing Mahomes. Geezus.

Go Hawks

 

[MORGULON]

You're taking different things different people are saying, combining them, and then acting as if everyone criticizing him are being illogical. Haven't heard one single person who brings up those issues claiming he's worth that much.

I'm no NFL personnel expert ( obviously) but id agree with you in that DK wouldn't bring some silly haul of picks. I'm thinking maybe a 2nd and a 3rd? Something like that. Possibly a team with injuries trying to make a run offer more out of necessity.

Other teams track what's going on and negotiate accordingly

 

[MORGULON]

Agree to disagree on Geno. I'm done talking about this subject. You're not gonna' budge, and I'm not gonna' budge. Geno isn't on the same planet as Patrick f'ing Mahomes. Geezus.

Go Hawks

You're on the same planet as Mahommes Soulfish

 

[SoulfishHawk]

I wish. Dat dude good

 

[Appyhawk]

Mahomes has the "it" factor. Geno has the itch factor. That is the difference.

 

[SoulfishHawk]

You said it not me. But very well said