To re-sign or not to re-sign (defense)

To resign or not to (can pick multiple)

  • Leonard Williams (29.7)

  • Bobby Wagner (33.7)

  • Jordyn Brookes (26.3)

  • Darrell Taylor (26.9)

  • Devin Bush (25.6)

  • Mario Edwards (30.1)

  • Michael Jackson (27.1)

  • Myles Adams (25.9)

  • Joshua Onujiogu (26)


Results are only viewable after voting.

Wsumatt1982

Active member
Joined
Jan 13, 2024
Messages
119
Reaction score
144
I vote none. I like a couple here but all replaceable. I like brooks the most but am fine if we don’t bring him back honestly
 

DarkVictory23

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 9, 2021
Messages
1,174
Reaction score
1,801
I don't get the 'blow it all up' stuff. Like, we can't, for one. We have lots of dudes who are already on the roster.

But also, it just seems so illogical. Do we really think there is not a single player on the team who represents good value at their position relative to who can be got from other teams? Do they have cooties from being here while Carroll was coach?

Like, Leonard Williams is just flat out a good player. Does the 'Mike Macdonald way' not involve good players?

Jordyn Brooks is probably going to command a deal about half of what Queen is going to get. Even if you don't think they're comparable (I do), Queen is definitely not twice as good.

I also voted for Mike Jackson, he's worth a RFA tender I think. (And if he signs somewhere else, we get comp, so there's that.)


Outside of those 3, I also voted for Bobby, but I only want him brought back under certain circumstances, not in the same role as in 2023.
 
Top