In a study including 147 players over a decade, only 26 prospects were up to par with Holmes, and 12 of those 26 came as first-round picks, not including the likes of Justin Houston, who was considered a first-round talent but fell due to a failed drug test at the combine. Outside of the elite of the elite prospects, you really have to dig to find players who are on Holmes' level.
When using the "twitch" metric from Waldo to filter more players, the number of comparable athletes drops even further:
First round: J.J. Watt, Von Miller, DeMarcus Ware, Melvin Ingram, Bruce Irvin, Jerry Hughes, Brandon Graham, Adam Carriker and Jamaal Anderson
Second round: Connor Barwin and Turk McBride
Third round: Chris Gocong
Fourth round: None