Position rankings, NFC West

[bileever]

Mike Clay recently did a ranking for each position group for each team in the NFL. Because it's a slow news week, I thought I'd post the position ranking for each team in the NFC West.

Position	Seahawks	49ers	Rams	Cardinals
QB	19	24	15	22
RB	2	1	29	27
WR	2	11	25	22
TE	14	3	21	32
OL	23	26	30	27
DT	26	2	11	32
EDGE	28	17	32	30
LB	4	1	32	27
CB	15	24	32	30
S	5	8	29	11
Overall	16	15	32	31

It's a very flawed analysis; he underestimates our roster at QB, OL, EDGE, and CB but over-values our RBs, safeties, and linebackers. He's equally blind to the 49ers' strength, ranking them at 17 at edge rusher, 24 at QB and 26 at OL.

He's really not impressed by the Rams or Cardinals at most of the positions, for good reason. The article itself is behind a paywall, which is why I made the above chart. (You're welcome.)

Ranking every NFL position group, 1-32: Which teams earn best, worst and most improved honors?

We graded positions for every NFL team and stacked them 1 to 32. Who has the best overall roster? And which team should you watch out for in 2023?

www.espn.com

Discuss amongst yourselves. And remember, don't shoot me, I'm only the messenger.

 

[Maulbert]

Mike Clay recently did a ranking for each position group for each team in the NFL. Because it's a slow news week, I thought I'd post the position ranking for each team in the NFC West.

Position	Seahawks	49ers	Rams	Cardinals
QB	19	24	15	22
RB	2	1	29	27
WR	2	11	25	22
TE	14	3	21	32
OL	23	26	30	27
DT	26	2	11	32
EDGE	28	17	32	30
LB	4	1	32	27
CB	15	24	32	30
S	5	8	29	11
Overall	16	15	32	31

It's a very flawed analysis; he underestimates our roster at QB, OL, EDGE, and CB but over-values our RBs, safeties, and linebackers. He's equally blind to the 49ers' strength, ranking them at 17 at edge rusher, 24 at QB and 26 at OL.

He's really not impressed by the Rams or Cardinals at most of the positions, for good reason. The article itself is behind a paywall, which is why I made the above chart. (You're welcome.)

Ranking every NFL position group, 1-32: Which teams earn best, worst and most improved honors?

We graded positions for every NFL team and stacked them 1 to 32. Who has the best overall roster? And which team should you watch out for in 2023?

www.espn.com

Discuss amongst yourselves. And remember, don't shoot me, I'm only the messenger.

The question I ask about his ranking of the 49ers edge rushers is if he rated them with or without Bosa. If it's with, then they're definitely undervalued. Also, no way 'Damn kids and their cellphones' Stafford is the best QB in the division anymore. I'd take Geno or Purdy over him. His shoulder is held together by spit and bailing wire.

 

[49fansinceBrodie]

ESPN is redefining 'experts'

 

[RedAlice]

Don’t agree with Mike. Do like the concept.

Thanks for sharing!

 

[morgulon1]

Thanks Bileever

 

[toffee]

We have better OL than 9ers?

 

[bileever]

I just saw that Frank Raines on fieldgulls.com did an article on this:

ESPN analyst Seahawks overall roster ranking is a middling one

Agree or disagree? Let’s discuss.

www.fieldgulls.com

 

[bileever]

We have better OL than 9ers?

I think the consensus is that with the loss of Mike McGlinchey that the 49ers' O-line--with the exception of Trent Williams--is not good. PFF ranks them at #18 after being #7 last year. But yes, #26 is probably too low when you have Trent Williams at LT. I think the respective strengths of our line and their line will determine a lot for 2023. A lot of what Shanahan likes to do starts with the run blocking of their O-line, and that's what McGlinchey was good at.

 

[flv2]

Information:

ESPN's pay-wall is in fact a Geo-location block. If you're using a US IP you have to pay. If you're using a European IP there isn't a block. Translation: set your VPN to UK or Netherlands for ESPN.com and you won't be blocked.

 

[Jville]

Information:

ESPN's pay-wall is in fact a Geo-location block. If you're using a US IP you have to pay. If you're using a European IP there isn't a block. Translation: set your VPN to UK or Netherlands for ESPN.com and you won't be blocked.

Surely an obvious AI switching application is in the offering soon.

 

[flv2]

Surely an obvious AI switching application is in the offering soon.

Companies will use AI to protect their intellectual property and increase revenue. People will use AI to circumvent the companies' AI. Never-ending circle.

 

[Ramfan128]

Yes definitely the worst I've seen all off season which is saying something.

There is no way we should be 32. Our WRs at 25 is mind bending unless they're ignoring Kupp completely

 

[Fernie Hawks Fan]

Information:

ESPN's pay-wall is in fact a Geo-location block. If you're using a US IP you have to pay. If you're using a European IP there isn't a block. Translation: set your VPN to UK or Netherlands for ESPN.com and you won't be blocked.

I'm in Canada and no pay-wall....sans VPN.

 

[SeAhAwKeR4life]

Well this story is OBVIOUSLY wrong since Brock Purdy is guaranteed to exceed Tom Brady in every regard!

Experts are saying Tom Brady and Peyton Manning combined very likely are not equal to 1/10th of Purdy's talents.

He'll win THREE Superb Owls this year alone! BANK IT!