Lou Pinella

[Hawkinaz]

No, but im not. They both are my favorite manager to ever manage a Mariners team. So, no nice try. They are equal to me. However, people look at Lou differently and fans back then did what ppl do on Servais.

And yes i agree. Lou had hall of fame players. He never got Seattle to the WS. Not even once. Not even when favored in 1997. Lost in ALDS. Geesh.

Scott got bagged on for losing to champion Houston when Houston was favored. I love both but ppl look fondly at the past.

Good talks tho!!

During the mid 90s through the mid 2000s the Yankees got in the way at the time they were a well oiled machine and Pinella‘s inability to handle pitchers

 

[Shanegotyou11]

Here are the top 5 managers of all time, by Wins Above Expectancy (based on WAR):

1. 84.1 Wilbert Robinson
2. 80.7 Mike Scioscia
3. 67.9 Connie Mack
4. 67.4 Bruce Bochy
5. 62.4 Bobby Cox

 

[Shanegotyou11]

And the bottom :

1. -63.1 Gene Mauch
2. -52.2 Eric Wedge
3. -47.0 Mike Hargrove
4. -45.0 Lou Piniella

 

[Threedee]

And the bottom :

1. -63.1 Gene Mauch
2. -52.2 Eric Wedge
3. -47.0 Mike Hargrove
4. -45.0 Lou Piniella

Three Mariners managers, FTW!