Marvin49":37dfp23r said:bigtrain21":37dfp23r said:Marvin49":37dfp23r said:bigtrain21":37dfp23r said:Marvin, do you honestly think a better throw would have resulted in a reception? No matter where he threw that ball it was getting deflected or intercepted. Sherman was in perfect position.
Note: I am not saying this makes Kaepernick a terrible qb, I am just tired of the narrative that a better throw wins the game for the 49ers. The problem with that narrative, Crabtree wasn't open on the play.
Debatable...but that ain't the point. The point is that the statement was ablout defending Crabtree, not making an excuse for losing. He was taking the blame for not throwing a good enough pass. The point is that If Kap does his job and B=Crabtree makes the catch then Sherman "mediocre" comments seems pretty ludicrous.
But Crabtree's job is to get open and he wasn't open on the play at all. Sherman perfectly covered that.
I have no problem with him taking the blame and that is honorable, however, he was wrong in acting like Crabtree was open and he was wrong in stating a better throw would have made Sherman the goat. Sherman did his job on the play.
As I said....whether Kap is right or wrong is irrelevant. We are talking about his motivation for making the comment.
As I thought.SF49r":2oonttco said:Your first post, you say Kaepernick got lucky because Earl Thomas didn't make the play. So I am saying Wilson got lucky Carlos Rogers didn't make the play.
bigtrain21":346onqrd said:Marvin49":346onqrd said:bigtrain21":346onqrd said:Marvin49":346onqrd said:Debatable...but that ain't the point. The point is that the statement was ablout defending Crabtree, not making an excuse for losing. He was taking the blame for not throwing a good enough pass. The point is that If Kap does his job and B=Crabtree makes the catch then Sherman "mediocre" comments seems pretty ludicrous.
But Crabtree's job is to get open and he wasn't open on the play at all. Sherman perfectly covered that.
I have no problem with him taking the blame and that is honorable, however, he was wrong in acting like Crabtree was open and he was wrong in stating a better throw would have made Sherman the goat. Sherman did his job on the play.
As I said....whether Kap is right or wrong is irrelevant. We are talking about his motivation for making the comment.
Really? It doesn't matter if he is right or wrong with his comment? Are you serious?
I do want to know where you stand on that play though even though I think your comment above is silly.
Laloosh":1nv8tknx said:Marv, the more you defend the lies, the more I think you secretly dislike your QB.
Sports Hernia":2ch56ymo said:No offense, but I disagree. The Kraepper is a one trick pony IMHO. He can win ball games with his legs, but loses them with his very poor decision making, and his one read and run mentality which comes back to bite him when playing good defenses. If he was my QB they guy would drive me to drink!!!byau":2ch56ymo said:Ehh..for me it's just getting back into camp. I personally am scared of Kaep. I think he's got a really high ceiling and if he can get past some maturation issues he's going to be deadly.
Thank gawd for Wilson!
RolandDeschain":2rije6jc said:Marvin, it doesn't help that Kaepernick has factually lied about some things, like saying Crabtree went for over 100 yards against Sherman when in fact Crabtree has yet to come within a hundred miles of sniffing a triple-digit day against Sherman.
Just sayin'.
byau":1quh77v9 said:Sports Hernia":1quh77v9 said:No offense, but I disagree. The Kraepper is a one trick pony IMHO. He can win ball games with his legs, but loses them with his very poor decision making, and his one read and run mentality which comes back to bite him when playing good defenses. If he was my QB they guy would drive me to drink!!!byau":1quh77v9 said:Ehh..for me it's just getting back into camp. I personally am scared of Kaep. I think he's got a really high ceiling and if he can get past some maturation issues he's going to be deadly.
Thank gawd for Wilson!
Good points. To me that is maturation. He is too quick to run. Russell has the maturation to look for the throw first. I know that can frustrate a lot of Seahawks fans when it looks like he has SUCH an open field. But I like that Russell has a habit to look for his first, second, third, and fourth read and more.
Kaep to me seems to be a first read, then run. Maybe first read, second read run. He seems to get caught up on that first read only. A lot.
(and I don't watch enough games of him so if you disagree, so be it ... my comments below will assume the above)
During the NFCCC, his first read then run killed the Hawks in the first half. The Hawks adjusted. But Kaep couldn't get rid of those habits
The fact that he does so well and the 49ers do so well with him being so LIMITED in reading ability is scary.
As soon as he matures into looking minimum first and second read ... maybe even more, and that he doesn't have to run, that will be scary.
A lot of sports talk radio shows are discussing RG3 and how the more athletic quarterbacks tend to rely too much on running too early.
This is why I think Russell is mature and why Kaep isn't. And why I say if Kaep matures, he will be scary.
Second example of immaturity: Kaep has to realize what the right move is. Come on you have to be honest that in the NFCCC he wanted to BEAT Sherman. He wanted to send the 49ers to the Super Bowl on a touchdown to Crabtree that beat Sherman. While it's good to have the mentality that you can beat anyone, it's also good to realize on a first read there was no way he would get Crabtree that pass. And since the Hawks took away the run the second half, he would either have to take the sack (which is still a good move - Russell takes a sack instead of forcing an error .. (see: Malcom Smith/SuperBowl)) or force the ball.
Once Kaep learns this mental side, he will be so much better than he is now, and what is he now? A quarterback who in the last two years took his team to the Super Bowl and came one score away from doing it again.
RolandDeschain":12psswds said:I know, but just try to realize what that looks like from our perspective. It looks like petulant sour grapes from a man who just can't let go.
loafoftatupu":7bdm2yrg said:Me too.byau":7bdm2yrg said:Ehh..for me it's just getting back into camp. I personally am scared of Kaep. I think he's got a really high ceiling and if he can get past some maturation issues he's going to be deadly.
The awesomeness just has "high ceiling" written all over it.
I know that when I see KaeperSpaz come on the field, I tremble at what he could be if he ever hit his incredibly high and unimaginable ceiling. I'm positive this season, based on the growth between 2012-2013, that KaeperSpaz will be an entirely matured quarterback in 2014.
:shock:
Marvin49":2s7kfj8u said:byau":2s7kfj8u said:Sports Hernia":2s7kfj8u said:No offense, but I disagree. The Kraepper is a one trick pony IMHO. He can win ball games with his legs, but loses them with his very poor decision making, and his one read and run mentality which comes back to bite him when playing good defenses. If he was my QB they guy would drive me to drink!!!byau":2s7kfj8u said:Ehh..for me it's just getting back into camp. I personally am scared of Kaep. I think he's got a really high ceiling and if he can get past some maturation issues he's going to be deadly.
Thank gawd for Wilson!
Good points. To me that is maturation. He is too quick to run. Russell has the maturation to look for the throw first. I know that can frustrate a lot of Seahawks fans when it looks like he has SUCH an open field. But I like that Russell has a habit to look for his first, second, third, and fourth read and more.
Kaep to me seems to be a first read, then run. Maybe first read, second read run. He seems to get caught up on that first read only. A lot.
(and I don't watch enough games of him so if you disagree, so be it ... my comments below will assume the above)
During the NFCCC, his first read then run killed the Hawks in the first half. The Hawks adjusted. But Kaep couldn't get rid of those habits
The fact that he does so well and the 49ers do so well with him being so LIMITED in reading ability is scary.
As soon as he matures into looking minimum first and second read ... maybe even more, and that he doesn't have to run, that will be scary.
A lot of sports talk radio shows are discussing RG3 and how the more athletic quarterbacks tend to rely too much on running too early.
This is why I think Russell is mature and why Kaep isn't. And why I say if Kaep matures, he will be scary.
Second example of immaturity: Kaep has to realize what the right move is. Come on you have to be honest that in the NFCCC he wanted to BEAT Sherman. He wanted to send the 49ers to the Super Bowl on a touchdown to Crabtree that beat Sherman. While it's good to have the mentality that you can beat anyone, it's also good to realize on a first read there was no way he would get Crabtree that pass. And since the Hawks took away the run the second half, he would either have to take the sack (which is still a good move - Russell takes a sack instead of forcing an error .. (see: Malcom Smith/SuperBowl)) or force the ball.
Once Kaep learns this mental side, he will be so much better than he is now, and what is he now? A quarterback who in the last two years took his team to the Super Bowl and came one score away from doing it again.
Big fat BS.
He had Sherman one on one. No safety help. Its that simple. That's the call regardless of who the DB is. Now I'll agree with you all day if you wanna argue the call, but Kap went there because he had Crab one on one on a DB. Its that simple. Its a pre-snap read. Its also a double move and the ball is thrown before the receiver would break open. The assumption there is that Crab makes the move and breaks free. Obviously, he didn't.
Marvin49":25chdqm4 said:The Niners lost the Super Bowl the year before. For them it was all about getting back...not trying to play out some vendetta against Richard Sherman.
To suggest otherwise is ludicrous.
byau":1ym5kv6p said:Marvin49":1ym5kv6p said:byau":1ym5kv6p said:Sports Hernia":1ym5kv6p said:No offense, but I disagree. The Kraepper is a one trick pony IMHO. He can win ball games with his legs, but loses them with his very poor decision making, and his one read and run mentality which comes back to bite him when playing good defenses. If he was my QB they guy would drive me to drink!!!
Thank gawd for Wilson!
Good points. To me that is maturation. He is too quick to run. Russell has the maturation to look for the throw first. I know that can frustrate a lot of Seahawks fans when it looks like he has SUCH an open field. But I like that Russell has a habit to look for his first, second, third, and fourth read and more.
Kaep to me seems to be a first read, then run. Maybe first read, second read run. He seems to get caught up on that first read only. A lot.
(and I don't watch enough games of him so if you disagree, so be it ... my comments below will assume the above)
During the NFCCC, his first read then run killed the Hawks in the first half. The Hawks adjusted. But Kaep couldn't get rid of those habits
The fact that he does so well and the 49ers do so well with him being so LIMITED in reading ability is scary.
As soon as he matures into looking minimum first and second read ... maybe even more, and that he doesn't have to run, that will be scary.
A lot of sports talk radio shows are discussing RG3 and how the more athletic quarterbacks tend to rely too much on running too early.
This is why I think Russell is mature and why Kaep isn't. And why I say if Kaep matures, he will be scary.
Second example of immaturity: Kaep has to realize what the right move is. Come on you have to be honest that in the NFCCC he wanted to BEAT Sherman. He wanted to send the 49ers to the Super Bowl on a touchdown to Crabtree that beat Sherman. While it's good to have the mentality that you can beat anyone, it's also good to realize on a first read there was no way he would get Crabtree that pass. And since the Hawks took away the run the second half, he would either have to take the sack (which is still a good move - Russell takes a sack instead of forcing an error .. (see: Malcom Smith/SuperBowl)) or force the ball.
Once Kaep learns this mental side, he will be so much better than he is now, and what is he now? A quarterback who in the last two years took his team to the Super Bowl and came one score away from doing it again.
Big fat BS.
He had Sherman one on one. No safety help. Its that simple. That's the call regardless of who the DB is. Now I'll agree with you all day if you wanna argue the call, but Kap went there because he had Crab one on one on a DB. Its that simple. Its a pre-snap read. Its also a double move and the ball is thrown before the receiver would break open. The assumption there is that Crab makes the move and breaks free. Obviously, he didn't.
have you seen that "tip" video someone put together? That was tight tight TIGHT coverage. Even with a push-off, Sherman stayed with him. That was some risky business. And if you look at Kaep, he did not EVEN look anywhere else. He looked at Crabtree the entire way. That to me is a stubborn one-read only play.
Laloosh":3uxt00gw said:Marvin49":3uxt00gw said:The Niners lost the Super Bowl the year before. For them it was all about getting back...not trying to play out some vendetta against Richard Sherman.
To suggest otherwise is ludicrous.
C'mon, Marv. You really don't put any stock in the idea that those two may have forced things a bit in an effort to make Sherm the guy who lost the big game?
Not such a reach for me personally. Look at his face when Sherm won break-out player of the year at the Espy awards. That's hate. Scurrying to the locker room before time has run off of the clock in another poor outing in SEA proves that he's a poor sport. Why wouldn't he make it personal? Look what he did to Cam Newton.
Face it. He's a bit of a punk kid. May change but for now he's got some sand in his crack.
No, we just don't appreciate an enemy player lying about one of our own.Marvin49":1i12s62i said:RolandDeschain":1i12s62i said:I know, but just try to realize what that looks like from our perspective. It looks like petulant sour grapes from a man who just can't let go.
if you choose to take every word he says as a personal affront and think any word said about the game is some sort of disrespect...then yeah, I can see why you guys think that.