Harvin - "ailing hip"....(labrum)

[davidonmi]

His season probably isn't over, Clayton said worst case 13 weeks, best case 9

 

[Cartire]

His season probably isn't over, Clayton said worst case 13 weeks, best case 9

How can he give a best case of 9 if we don't even know if he needs surgery?

 

[bestfightstory]

His season probably isn't over, Clayton said worst case 13 weeks, best case 9

So you are claiming that Clayton has declared Harvin OUT for 9 weeks minimum?

 

[NinerLifer]

His season probably isn't over, Clayton said worst case 13 weeks, best case 9

How can he give a best case of 9 if we don't even know if he needs surgery?

If he doesn't "need" surgery now...defenders will make sure he "needs" it before week 9.

 

[therealjohncarlson]

His season probably isn't over, Clayton said worst case 13 weeks, best case 9

What a guessing hack. I would love to get paid millions of bucks to be a professional guesser too!

 

[JSeahawks]

His season probably isn't over, Clayton said worst case 13 weeks, best case 9

What a guessing hack. I would love to get paid millions of bucks to be a professional guesser too!

That's IF he requires surgery. (which I don't think he will)

 

[SeaTown81]

His season probably isn't over, Clayton said worst case 13 weeks, best case 9

How can he give a best case of 9 if we don't even know if he needs surgery?

If he doesn't "need" surgery now...defenders will make sure he "needs" it before week 9.

Yeah, just like how defenders are going to be gunning for that 2 read, run happy qb of yours.

Seriously guys. Why do we let Niner fans troll our main board so much now? Its really offputting to have to read constantly. Makes me second guess how much time i want to spend on the site. I come to discuss Hawks. Not read Niner fans having to give their 2 cents on every subject.

 

[NinerLifer]

Wondering though...

If given the option, would you rather Harvin decide to go ahead with surgery if it means that he would be available prior to the post-season, or would some of you rather him elect to not have surgery at all and take the chance of him injuring it further which would result in him missing the remainder of the season from that point?

There are disadvantages to both scenarios, but given that defenders will no doubt target that hip if he doesn't elect surgery, choosing to have the surgery now would possibly be in his and your teams best interest.

I'm sure the fact that San Francisco has to play in Seattle on September 15 has no bearing on your opinion, right?

Actually the opposite. Harvin or no Harvin, C-Link is tough to win at so I don't think that Harvin not being in uniform that game will have that big of an effect on the outcome.

If he starts the season, like I said above, defenders will target that hip when tackling him and will eventually end his season, which would hurt you guys more by not having him in the case you make the playoffs. Also having him on the field without surgery will mean that he isn't 100% and won't be able to cut and escape tackles as well as he used to.

So if he is on the field week 2 against Willis, Bowman, The Smiths, etc....I think he would actually helping our team more than yours, since a single hit by either of them could be his last of the season. Having him return a single kick without surgery at any point in the season without surgery might as well be a one way ticket to IR.

So as a fan of football, and out of respect for the player, I think he would be smart to elect surgery now if required.

 

[hawksfansinceday1]

Seriously guys. Why do we let Niner fans troll our main board so much now? Its really offputting to have to read constantly. Makes me second guess how much time i want to spend on the site. I come to discuss Hawks. Not read Niner fans having to give their 2 cents on every subject.

Could not agree more.

 

[Floridahawk79]

Why are Niner fans on here so much? Don't they have their own forum?
L

 

[Zebulon Dak]

Seriously guys. Why do we let Niner fans troll our main board so much now? Its really offputting to have to read constantly. Makes me second guess how much time i want to spend on the site. I come to discuss Hawks. Not read Niner fans having to give their 2 cents on every subject.

Could not agree more.

BAN THEM ALLL!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[davidonmi]

His season probably isn't over, Clayton said worst case 13 weeks, best case 9

What a guessing hack. I would love to get paid millions of bucks to be a professional guesser too!

I should've included if he needs surgery

 

[SNDavidson]

Maybe our forum colors match their "kicks" better? Or is it just their wangster qb that does that?

 

[KEWASTEES]

Soooo...what are the chances hid season is done before starting?

I am actually just planning on him not being on the field all season while he watches his team tear it up.

Exactly

 

[Rocket]

I heard Kaepernick has a torn labia.

Not true. He's also got Testicular Tortion, AKA twisted nuts.

 

[Seahwkgal]

Seriously guys. Why do we let Niner fans troll our main board so much now? Its really offputting to have to read constantly. Makes me second guess how much time i want to spend on the site. I come to discuss Hawks. Not read Niner fans having to give their 2 cents on every subject.

:13: :13: :13: :13: :13: :13: :13:
I am also contemplating not posting here much anymore because of this. There is another Hawk board I check out from time to time but that one has way less whiner 'blah" "blah" "blah".
I will probably be over there more if these niner trolls don't start disappearing.

 

[Bakergirl]

Ok, either way our recieving core is strong without him, providing Harvin is going to miss some time, let's hope Harper can step into the limelight and have some success fairly quickly as our #4.

Your wide receiver core may be fine, but IF he is on the PUP list to start the season, I think this really hurts your ST/return game, especially after letting Leon Washington go.

agreed, who's next to do the return duties if Harvin is out? Lane?

Golden Tate isn't half bad in the return game.

 

[Axx]

Clayton isn't a doctor though

 

[Lady Talon]

Debates making another Kaepernick thread so whiners can go gang post and derail that instead...

 

[ClumsyLurk]

Question, when is it OK to start feeling bummed about this trade?