Without penalties for keeping the players, the former. With penalties, Hyde might be a better value buy, especially given Megatron's potential health issues.
In case anyone cares heresbhow my team shook out today. It was actually only 1 keeper but I was figuring those 2 scenarios above were my most likely outcomes.
QB Rapist
RB Forte Hyde Gurley Mason K. Robinson B. Bolden B. Brown
WR Green Smith sr. S. Johnson Harvin
TE Walker
D/ST Browns
K Sturgis