RiverDog
Well-known member
TwistedHusky":1wn2qdbr said:Putting aside my venting and complaining about Pete for a second, since that is more catharsis.
There are only 2 reasons you fire Pete or get rid of him:
1 - Wilson wants him gone and will not stay unless he leaves
2 - Wilson is leaving and the only way to keep him is to get rid of Pete.
That is really it.
The chances of getting another coach that can consistently win is pretty low. With this ownership, likely even lower.
However, the chances of getting another QB that can produce even close to Wilson's success is significantly worse. And the chances of getting any QB that can get us to the playoffs under Pete Carroll is less than that.
So it all depends on Wilson. The rest does not matter.
I don't agree. Russell is without a doubt a top 10 and arguably a top 5 QB, but I don't think the prospects for replacing his production are as dire as you're making them out to be.
A lot would depend on how he were to leave. If he left via trade and we got something like the Bears were reportedly offering a few months ago, then the likelihood of find someone that can "come even close" to Wilson's success, which hasn't been all that Earth shattering recently, is at least decent. We could end up with a player like Deshaun Watson, whose ceiling is certainly high enough to match what Russell has given us over the past couple of years.
And before I get jumped, that doesn't mean I'm advocating a trade. I'm simply saying that the world doesn't begin and end with Russell.