Popeyejones":3j6drr72 said:
Absolutely, absolutely agreed w/ all this, although that doesn't change my original statement that with that defensive performance on that play call with that ball placement I don't think anyone catches that pass for a TD.
A bigger-bodied receiver than Lockette probably gets knocked away a little less by Butler and it becomes an incompletion instead of a game-ending pick. The receivers in that category would mostly be TEs. Or hell, put Tukuafu in at FB and then split him out.
So let's call Lockette out for only being 200-ish instead of 250 or 270.
Neither Wilson nor Lockette had any idea Butler was there. It was a mental failure on both parts, compounding a mental failure on Bevell's part.
Why didn't Bevell call out Kearse on not being "stronger to the pick" against Browner? Because it would have shown how ludicrous Bevell's play design was for that matchup, expecting 200-ish Kearse to push 240-ish Browner off the line. And of course Wilson then failed to read that matchup problem, and either audible out, or go somewhere else with the ball.
So it took about 7 mental and physical failures on that play by Seattle and about 5 outstanding mental and physical plays by NE (Browner and Butler) to give that result. +12 for NE on one play.
- Bevell, poor play concept, not using most dangerous weapons for that scenario
- Wilson, failing to see the matchup issue and audible out or go elsewhere with the ball (mental)
- Wilson, failing to see Butler lurking (physical--too short)
- Wilson, poor ball placement (mental)
- Kearse, failing to successfully push Browner into Butler's way (physical)
- Lockette, failing to be aware Butler was anywhere around (mental)
- Lockette, being too light to keep Butler from knocking him off the ball (physical)
+ Browner, reading what was coming (mental)
+ Browner, winning the LOS battle vs smaller receiver (physical)
+ Butler, also reading what was coming
+ Butler, breaking on the ball
+ Butler, making the pick
For Bevell to throw an inexperienced receiver like Lockette under the bus for not turning chicken poop into chicken salad, was simply disgusting. Thankfully, Wilson and Carroll showed much more class.