JimmyB3
New member
Only thing that bothers me about this is that Cam Newton will be rated higher.
Hawks46":12ezt3zm said:Wondering how high Lynch, Okung and Sherman willl go. Any other Seahawks make the list ?
I'm thinking Chancellor makes the list. As hard as he hits, you bet your ass there's a ton of WRs and TEs out there that will rate him highly.
Hawks46":1lrq0qtr said:Wilson is rated 11th of QBs, meaning 10 are above him. So I'm thinking....
Rodgers, Brady, Manning, Brees. I get these since they've been doing it over and over and they are proven. Maybe Eli Manning for the same reason. So who's rated higher as a QB ? I'm trying to think....Stafford has already been rated. I think the overall ranking is fine, but I can't find 10 QBs better than Wilson at this point.
JimmyB3":fgkb7ft7 said:Only thing that bothers me about this is that Cam Newton will be rated higher.
HunnyBadger":1qne4p36 said:JimmyB3":1qne4p36 said:Only thing that bothers me about this is that Cam Newton will be rated higher.
Where is it stated yet that Cam is on the list? He wouldn't make top 100 IMO based on his last year's performance.
drdiags":cpakgh3t said:Hawks46":cpakgh3t said:Wilson is rated 11th of QBs, meaning 10 are above him. So I'm thinking....
Rodgers, Brady, Manning, Brees. I get these since they've been doing it over and over and they are proven. Maybe Eli Manning for the same reason. So who's rated higher as a QB ? I'm trying to think....Stafford has already been rated. I think the overall ranking is fine, but I can't find 10 QBs better than Wilson at this point.
Good question. My stab at who the players may have picked for the top 10 QBs (not saying I agree with them, but this is their poll):
In no order of ranking
1 - Brady
2 - Rodgers
3 - P Manning
4 - Drew Brees
5 - E Manning
6 - Cam Newton
7 - A Luck
8 - J Cutler
9 - RGIII
10 - Romo (Thought I heard he wasn't on the list? Not sure)
Others to pick from Dalton, Schaub, Freeman(?) and Tannehill
Already rated in top 100 as a comparison
1 - Stafford
2 - Roethlisberger
3 - Kaepernick
Of that list I see Wilson as better than Cam Newton on down and likely at least even with Eli Manning. And every bit as good as Ryan and Flacco who will be on the list.drdiags":1d3oztl4 said:Hawks46":1d3oztl4 said:Wilson is rated 11th of QBs, meaning 10 are above him. So I'm thinking....
Rodgers, Brady, Manning, Brees. I get these since they've been doing it over and over and they are proven. Maybe Eli Manning for the same reason. So who's rated higher as a QB ? I'm trying to think....Stafford has already been rated. I think the overall ranking is fine, but I can't find 10 QBs better than Wilson at this point.
Good question. My stab at who the players may have picked for the top 10 QBs (not saying I agree with them, but this is their poll):
In no order of ranking
1 - Brady
2 - Rodgers
3 - P Manning
4 - Drew Brees
5 - E Manning
6 - Cam Newton
7 - A Luck
8 - J Cutler
9 - RGIII
10 - Romo (Thought I heard he wasn't on the list? Not sure)
Others to pick from Dalton, Schaub, Freeman(?) and Tannehill
Already rated in top 100 as a comparison
1 - Stafford
2 - Roethlisberger
3 - Kaepernick
Jerhawk":9ercplw3 said:51 was a fair spot for Russell. Very impressive, and I'm sure he's honored by it
jlwaters1":jzslmiq8 said:Your missing Flacco and Ryan, BOTH will most likely be on the list .
HunnyBadger":3sb05cae said:JimmyB3":3sb05cae said:Only thing that bothers me about this is that Cam Newton will be rated higher.
Where is it stated yet that Cam is on the list? He wouldn't make top 100 IMO based on his last year's performance.