Geno, admittedly, yes I am a massive fan. DK kinda pissed me off but I liked that he was a physical unicorn and had fire. I don't mind losing DK and, sure, while I personally hate losing Geno my issue is really how this went down.
I think what makes us look bad is that they both requested to get out. I think it looks bad that the impression being echoed by former players about the organization is that they feel like no one could ever finish their career here. I think it looks bad that these trades were reactive decisions rather than proactive plans.
I don't think a full rebuild is appropriate after an ascendant season, and I don't think anyone in the FO or coaching staff would agree that they are rebuilding. I don't think they have that type of leash, and I think they all get fired within 2 years if they don't keep improving.
The void I think Pete filled is one of culture and vision. I don't think (debatably) cornerstone guys wanted to leave as bad as they seem to now. I think Mike is a fantastic coach, but I think the organization is missing a CEO type to keep John, the staff, the players, etc. all on the same page.
I know we looked at Geno with opposing opinions, but that's here no there. I don't understand why you are bothered by how things went down. Geno wanted his payday and the FO didn't feel he was worth the asking price. It was business, nothing personal. Happens everyday in the NFL. DK lost his mentor and teammate with Tyler and i'm sure that stung. He also probably caught wind of Geno leaving before the rest of us did. Lastly, he was chasing money too. Happens. I don't feel any of it was bad blood for anybody on a personal level.
Who ever finishes their career with one team in the league in this day and age? I can't think of anybody. Maybe a star QB, but that's even a rarity in this day and age. I don't feel that's a factor in anybodys decision making. That's silly. The NFL became a business with the cap. You can't keep teams together like they did in the 70's.
How can the FO and staff not recognize that it's a rebuild when they themselves were the root of it? They blew up the entire identity of the offense. They didn't feel the offense with the aging Geno and Tyler along with an underachieving DK was worth keeping. MM and staff have a vision and those pieces didn't fit the puzzle anymore.
Culture I can understand, but the vision is where you lost me. I couldn't see where he was trying to go. I saw a coach that won just enough that the organization was in limbo, but was never getting over the hump to become a contender again. As for JS being kept in check, I think that was a two way street. Right now, John is on a prove it schedule. If he's as good as some think, he'll be fine. If not, he'll be gone.
I'm excited for the direction of the team right now. At least they are trying something different which is a fresh approach and dearly needed. Could it end up in a disaster,,,,,,sure. Could it be a thing of beauty,,,,you bet. Let's just give it a chance and enjoy the ride either way.