I believe JS has a hard line on what he's willing to pay a QB. If the rumors of Geno Smith wanting 40+ million a year are true and JS only offered a max of 35 Million, then I think we won't pay more than that for Sam Darnold. Those same rumors are saying that Darnold "has a soft market" value. We'll see what happens. I'm hopeful JS will start looking at QBs in the draft to develop. I'm tired of someone else's retreads.
A hardline on Geno, that is. Geno's issue is he's not really a remarkable QB. He wasn't bad, but he also wasn't that great either. He was a slightly above average QB that could pilot your offense, nothing more, nothing less. He's not the type of guy to elevate his team, typically the way the team went is the way he'd go. I'd argue that paying a QB that is going to be in his mid 30s, 40+ million a year with a fairly unremarkable track record would be a mistake on Seattle's part. Geno was not that great as a QB.
It looks as if the NFL agrees with this sentiment. In a league starved for QB's, Geno Smith only netted a 3rd round pick. It looks as if the Raiders were the only suitor for his services. It's not just his age either, Stafford netted at a similar age, two first round picks plus Jared Goff. Goff folded in the biggest moments for the Rams, it's no surprise that a QB like Stafford was able to take the helm and lead them to a SuperBowl win.
Geno is what he is, the new Kirk Cousins. A QB that is just good enough, but falls short in big situations. Now people point to his 4th Quarter comeback record and I have to scoff at that. Kirk Cousins, a QB blasted for faltering in big situations was one of the leader in 4th quarter comebacks. I'd argue that the 4th quarter comeback stat is not a great way to gage how good a guy is in big situations and clearly the NFL thinks the same thing about Smith.
Now, people that argue "hey look at Goff with the right situation!" Yeah, Goff had the perfect situation, a rare set of circumstances. He has one of the hottest offensive minds in football right now, paired with a strong offensive line, good running game and elite receiver corps. Geno is unlikely to get that here in Seattle. Even with a perfect set of circumstances, Goff played a horrible game against Washington.
His tendency to falter at just the right times came out. We needed to move on from him whether this your or the next.
Now, the issue here is a I hope that Darnold isn't the option for Seattle. Darnold was seeing ghost in the playoffs, his old habits reared their ugly heads. He could tell what was going on, it was an absolutely horrid performance by all metrics. He looked like a rookie that had never played an NFL game before. He had no answer and he looked shell shocked. His processing speed seems a bit slow. I'm not even sure how much of a bridge QB he would be and at what price would he come? We're potentially putting ourselves in an even worse position that we were with Geno.
i keep saying this and I'll say it again. Seattle really dropped the ball last year by not moving up in the draft last year to pick up a QB. Schneider has kicked the QB situation so far down the road that now we're stuck with Sam Howell and potentially Darnold. That is not a good position to be in as a franchise, particularly given that this is a very weak QB class and was known to be a pretty weak class even the year prior.