Seahawks Rookie grades do you agree?

[Chukarhawk]

Link below
what are your grades?

MSN

 

[Rat]

Those grades seem reasonable to me. Nobody on there I would say is considerably off.

Playing a game of "one higher, one lower":

One Higher - I'd take away the minus from AJ Barner's grade. I don't know what more you could have asked from him as a fourth-rounder who was barely involved in the receiving game in college. I know the grade is for the player and not the pick, but the front office and scouting team deserve enormous credit for seeing that potential in him.

One Lower - If whatever it was Christian Haynes was doing didn't earn an "F", then I'm just going to assume they only give those out to players who didn't make the team.

 

[Appyhawk]

Not sure about individual grades but I know I love our last two drafts. I sure do wish Reed would get past the injury bug cause I know that guy could play some serious ball as a DB/safety. He's a killer on ST.

 

[nwHawk]

Link below
what are your grades?

MSN

Christian Haynes… “On one hand, he posted a decent 96.6 percent pass blocking efficiency rate in limited action, which may be a positive sign for his future. However, his run blocking at the point of attack left much to be desired…”

Tell me that doesn’t sound like a future LG.