NINEster":3efiq3wq said:Kyle is top 3 OC
Unless you're up 28-3 in the Super Bowl. In that case, he's the worst offensive coordinator of all time.
NINEster":3efiq3wq said:Kyle is top 3 OC
Wow’s I somehow missed that gem from Ninertroll in his wall of text. All Shanny had to do was run the Ball and salt the clock away and Atlanta has a Lombardi trophy. OC’s getting “too cute” is the reason for 2 of the Cheatriots Lombardis.nanomoz":85rigyiu said:NINEster":85rigyiu said:Kyle is top 3 OC
Unless you're up 28-3 in the Super Bowl. In that case, he's the worst offensive coordinator of all time.
Sports Hernia":7fypvu2g said:Wow’s I somehow missed that gem from Ninertroll in his wall of text. All Shanny had to do was run the Ball and salt the clock away and Atlanta has a Lombardi trophy. OC’s getting “too cute” is the reason for 2 of the Cheatriots Lombardis.nanomoz":7fypvu2g said:NINEster":7fypvu2g said:Kyle is top 3 OC
Unless you're up 28-3 in the Super Bowl. In that case, he's the worst offensive coordinator of all time.
Shanny and Bevell.
Sorry, I disagree. He made a shit ton of mistakes in the Super Bowl against the Pats, a whole 2nd half’s worth.Marvin49":30p0ju6y said:Sports Hernia":30p0ju6y said:Wow’s I somehow missed that gem from Ninertroll in his wall of text. All Shanny had to do was run the Ball and salt the clock away and Atlanta has a Lombardi trophy. OC’s getting “too cute” is the reason for 2 of the Cheatriots Lombardis.nanomoz":30p0ju6y said:NINEster":30p0ju6y said:Kyle is top 3 OC
Unless you're up 28-3 in the Super Bowl. In that case, he's the worst offensive coordinator of all time.
Shanny and Bevell.
He didn't say Shanahan has never made any mistakes. He said he's a top 3 OC.
Is Wilson not a top 5 QB because he threw an INT on the goal line which cost them a title? Of course he's a top 5 QB. Don't be silly.
Shanahan is one of the best OCs in the NFL no matter how much you don't want it to be so.
I wasn’t aware that Shanahan was calling holding penalties and missed blocks.Sports Hernia":18ztt21u said:Sorry, I disagree. He made a shit ton of mistakes in the Super Bowl against the Pats, a whole 2nd half’s worth.Marvin49":18ztt21u said:Sports Hernia":18ztt21u said:Wow’s I somehow missed that gem from Ninertroll in his wall of text. All Shanny had to do was run the Ball and salt the clock away and Atlanta has a Lombardi trophy. OC’s getting “too cute” is the reason for 2 of the Cheatriots Lombardis.nanomoz":18ztt21u said:Unless you're up 28-3 in the Super Bowl. In that case, he's the worst offensive coordinator of all time.
Shanny and Bevell.
He didn't say Shanahan has never made any mistakes. He said he's a top 3 OC.
Is Wilson not a top 5 QB because he threw an INT on the goal line which cost them a title? Of course he's a top 5 QB. Don't be silly.
Shanahan is one of the best OCs in the NFL no matter how much you don't want it to be so.
I climb all over Darrell Bevell’s shit much to the dismay of many Hawks fans over one horrific play call which I never will forgive him for in a Super Bowl.
Saint Shanny made a whole half’s worth of shitty play calls in the biggest game of his life while having a 25 point lead at halftime !!!!!!!!!!
Top 3 OC’s don’t piss away 25 point halftime leads in Super Bowls, sorry.
That’s a weak deflection even for you.5_Golden_Rings":4plk66g8 said:I wasn’t aware that Shanahan was calling holding penalties and missed blocks.Sports Hernia":4plk66g8 said:Sorry, I disagree. He made a shit ton of mistakes in the Super Bowl against the Pats, a whole 2nd half’s worth.Marvin49":4plk66g8 said:Sports Hernia":4plk66g8 said:Wow’s I somehow missed that gem from Ninertroll in his wall of text. All Shanny had to do was run the Ball and salt the clock away and Atlanta has a Lombardi trophy. OC’s getting “too cute” is the reason for 2 of the Cheatriots Lombardis.
Shanny and Bevell.
He didn't say Shanahan has never made any mistakes. He said he's a top 3 OC.
Is Wilson not a top 5 QB because he threw an INT on the goal line which cost them a title? Of course he's a top 5 QB. Don't be silly.
Shanahan is one of the best OCs in the NFL no matter how much you don't want it to be so.
I climb all over Darrell Bevell’s shit much to the dismay of many Hawks fans over one horrific play call which I never will forgive him for in a Super Bowl.
Saint Shanny made a whole half’s worth of shitty play calls in the biggest game of his life while having a 25 point lead at halftime !!!!!!!!!!
Top 3 OC’s don’t piss away 25 point halftime leads in Super Bowls, sorry.
Best part about this fake argument: you know darn well you wish he was your team’s offensive coordinator. :stirthepot:
You can’t figure it out from my post? Really?Popeyejones":3ff1l4pg said:Wait, so are you saying you'd rather have Schotty than Shanahan or not?
It's okay, no need to deflect or talk around it. Just a one word answer and be honest.
Sports Hernia":2aaq532a said:You can’t figure it out from my post? Really?Popeyejones":2aaq532a said:Wait, so are you saying you'd rather have Schotty than Shanahan or not?
It's okay, no need to deflect or talk around it. Just a one word answer and be honest.
Sports Hernia":36t37932 said:That’s a weak deflection even for you.5_Golden_Rings":36t37932 said:I wasn’t aware that Shanahan was calling holding penalties and missed blocks.Sports Hernia":36t37932 said:Sorry, I disagree. He made a shit ton of mistakes in the Super Bowl against the Pats, a whole 2nd half’s worth.Marvin49":36t37932 said:He didn't say Shanahan has never made any mistakes. He said he's a top 3 OC.
Is Wilson not a top 5 QB because he threw an INT on the goal line which cost them a title? Of course he's a top 5 QB. Don't be silly.
Shanahan is one of the best OCs in the NFL no matter how much you don't want it to be so.
I climb all over Darrell Bevell’s shit much to the dismay of many Hawks fans over one horrific play call which I never will forgive him for in a Super Bowl.
Saint Shanny made a whole half’s worth of shitty play calls in the biggest game of his life while having a 25 point lead at halftime !!!!!!!!!!
Top 3 OC’s don’t piss away 25 point halftime leads in Super Bowls, sorry.
Best part about this fake argument: you know darn well you wish he was your team’s offensive coordinator. :stirthepot:
He called the passing plays when he should have been running. Again, he had a 25 point lead at halftime against Shady Brady. You run the ball, let the play clock get down to 2 seconds before snapping the ball, and Atlanta puts a Lombardi in the trophy case.
It doesn’t matter if you gain yards or not at that point. It’s not rocket science.
Let’s face it, and be honest, your golden boy crapped the bed.
I’m not the biggest fan of Schotty, but I wouldn’t want Shanny as the OC after choking away a Lombardi.
Sports Hernia":3azfa51o said:Sorry, I disagree. He made a shit ton of mistakes in the Super Bowl against the Pats, a whole 2nd half’s worth.Marvin49":3azfa51o said:Sports Hernia":3azfa51o said:Wow’s I somehow missed that gem from Ninertroll in his wall of text. All Shanny had to do was run the Ball and salt the clock away and Atlanta has a Lombardi trophy. OC’s getting “too cute” is the reason for 2 of the Cheatriots Lombardis.nanomoz":3azfa51o said:Unless you're up 28-3 in the Super Bowl. In that case, he's the worst offensive coordinator of all time.
Shanny and Bevell.
He didn't say Shanahan has never made any mistakes. He said he's a top 3 OC.
Is Wilson not a top 5 QB because he threw an INT on the goal line which cost them a title? Of course he's a top 5 QB. Don't be silly.
Shanahan is one of the best OCs in the NFL no matter how much you don't want it to be so.
I climb all over Darrell Bevell’s shit much to the dismay of many Hawks fans over one horrific play call which I never will forgive him for in a Super Bowl.
Saint Shanny made a whole half’s worth of shitty play calls in the biggest game of his life while having a 25 point lead at halftime !!!!!!!!!!
Top 3 OC’s don’t piss away 25 point halftime leads in Super Bowls, sorry.
Sports Hernia":osbj9ghn said:You can’t figure it out from my post? Really?Popeyejones":osbj9ghn said:Wait, so are you saying you'd rather have Schotty than Shanahan or not?
It's okay, no need to deflect or talk around it. Just a one word answer and be honest.
5_Golden_Rings":3kbscp45 said:Sports Hernia":3kbscp45 said:That’s a weak deflection even for you.5_Golden_Rings":3kbscp45 said:I wasn’t aware that Shanahan was calling holding penalties and missed blocks.Sports Hernia":3kbscp45 said:Sorry, I disagree. He made a shit ton of mistakes in the Super Bowl against the Pats, a whole 2nd half’s worth.
I climb all over Darrell Bevell’s shit much to the dismay of many Hawks fans over one horrific play call which I never will forgive him for in a Super Bowl.
Saint Shanny made a whole half’s worth of shitty play calls in the biggest game of his life while having a 25 point lead at halftime !!!!!!!!!!
Top 3 OC’s don’t piss away 25 point halftime leads in Super Bowls, sorry.
Best part about this fake argument: you know darn well you wish he was your team’s offensive coordinator. :stirthepot:
He called the passing plays when he should have been running. Again, he had a 25 point lead at halftime against Shady Brady. You run the ball, let the play clock get down to 2 seconds before snapping the ball, and Atlanta puts a Lombardi in the trophy case.
It doesn’t matter if you gain yards or not at that point. It’s not rocket science.
Let’s face it, and be honest, your golden boy crapped the bed.
I’m not the biggest fan of Schotty, but I wouldn’t want Shanny as the OC after choking away a Lombardi.
Lol liar.
Marvin49":2cp4wyzk said:Sports Hernia":2cp4wyzk said:Sorry, I disagree. He made a shit ton of mistakes in the Super Bowl against the Pats, a whole 2nd half’s worth.Marvin49":2cp4wyzk said:Sports Hernia":2cp4wyzk said:Wow’s I somehow missed that gem from Ninertroll in his wall of text. All Shanny had to do was run the Ball and salt the clock away and Atlanta has a Lombardi trophy. OC’s getting “too cute” is the reason for 2 of the Cheatriots Lombardis.
Shanny and Bevell.
He didn't say Shanahan has never made any mistakes. He said he's a top 3 OC.
Is Wilson not a top 5 QB because he threw an INT on the goal line which cost them a title? Of course he's a top 5 QB. Don't be silly.
Shanahan is one of the best OCs in the NFL no matter how much you don't want it to be so.
I climb all over Darrell Bevell’s shit much to the dismay of many Hawks fans over one horrific play call which I never will forgive him for in a Super Bowl.
Saint Shanny made a whole half’s worth of shitty play calls in the biggest game of his life while having a 25 point lead at halftime !!!!!!!!!!
Top 3 OC’s don’t piss away 25 point halftime leads in Super Bowls, sorry.
...missed in your argument....
1) He had amassed a 25 point lead in the first place.
2) He doesn't play defense.
3) Thay had the first down at the end if not for a holding call.
4) The Falcons under his leadership were one of the best offenses in NFL history that season and made Matt Ryan the league MVP. Matt. Ryan.
5) If Shanahan were the Seahawks OC, you'd be making the exact reverse argument you are making now.
Nobody is infallible. I'm sure there are many things Shanahan would like to do different if he had it back, but he was HARDLY the reason they lost, and was a HUGE reason they were even in that situation to begin with.
If Shanahan were fired, how long do you think it would take for him to get a job as an OC? He coached MATT SHAUB to a 98.6 QB rating. He coached RGIII to a 102.4 QB rating as a rookie. Matt Ryans rating was 117.1. His previous career high rating had been 99.1.
Hell, he played undrafted Free Agent Nick Mullens to a 90.8 rating and has several members of THIS BOARD saying the Niners already have their QB of the future over Jimmy and that Mullens should start.
What is REALLY interesting is seeing what happens to his QBs after he leaves.
GTFO. Shanahan is one of the best in the business as an OC and just about anyone who pays any attention will tell you that. The only people who don't think that are people who don't WANT it to be true.
Sports Hernia":2bmdwihe said:Marvin49":2bmdwihe said:Sports Hernia":2bmdwihe said:Sorry, I disagree. He made a shit ton of mistakes in the Super Bowl against the Pats, a whole 2nd half’s worth.Marvin49":2bmdwihe said:He didn't say Shanahan has never made any mistakes. He said he's a top 3 OC.
Is Wilson not a top 5 QB because he threw an INT on the goal line which cost them a title? Of course he's a top 5 QB. Don't be silly.
Shanahan is one of the best OCs in the NFL no matter how much you don't want it to be so.
I climb all over Darrell Bevell’s shit much to the dismay of many Hawks fans over one horrific play call which I never will forgive him for in a Super Bowl.
Saint Shanny made a whole half’s worth of shitty play calls in the biggest game of his life while having a 25 point lead at halftime !!!!!!!!!!
Top 3 OC’s don’t piss away 25 point halftime leads in Super Bowls, sorry.
...missed in your argument....
1) He had amassed a 25 point lead in the first place.
2) He doesn't play defense.
3) Thay had the first down at the end if not for a holding call.
4) The Falcons under his leadership were one of the best offenses in NFL history that season and made Matt Ryan the league MVP. Matt. Ryan.
5) If Shanahan were the Seahawks OC, you'd be making the exact reverse argument you are making now.
Nobody is infallible. I'm sure there are many things Shanahan would like to do different if he had it back, but he was HARDLY the reason they lost, and was a HUGE reason they were even in that situation to begin with.
If Shanahan were fired, how long do you think it would take for him to get a job as an OC? He coached MATT SHAUB to a 98.6 QB rating. He coached RGIII to a 102.4 QB rating as a rookie. Matt Ryans rating was 117.1. His previous career high rating had been 99.1.
Hell, he played undrafted Free Agent Nick Mullens to a 90.8 rating and has several members of THIS BOARD saying the Niners already have their QB of the future over Jimmy and that Mullens should start.
What is REALLY interesting is seeing what happens to his QBs after he leaves.
GTFO. Shanahan is one of the best in the business as an OC and just about anyone who pays any attention will tell you that. The only people who don't think that are people who don't WANT it to be true.
You dizzy from all that spin Marvin?
chris98251":29pyaq24 said:You can take Bevell and Shanny and see if you can make one OC with balls, both have a habit of choking like a fresh whore giving blow jobs. Some of it may have been Quinn and Carroll but even so over a season you can see the track record.
I don't care what the NFL says about ratings you never take your foot off the gas, we seen it in the Falcons game and in our games, going away from what works and getting cute is another aspect which both seem to think is clever and bites them in the ass.
Maulbert":23byqf87 said:Even conceding Shanahan is a top 3 OC, y'all seem to forget he's not Santa Clara's OC, he's their head coach.
And if you truly don't understand the significance of the difference, might I direct you to the career of one Norv Turner?