If You Could Add ANY Current Player…

[m0ng0]

Bobby Wagner

 

[Rat]

I wanna say Mahomes but Josh Allen is atleast right there. Without Andy Reid, Mahomes career could be a lot different and he owes a lot of his success to his system. Allen has gotten even better Without Diggs being a distraction and has literally put the entire offense on his back and been great(Cook is very good RB in that offense too).

Not sure I agree with this. Allen was one of the biggest boom or bust QB prospects in recent memory and I think he would have failed in more places than Mahomes would have. Yes, the Reid system is beneficial to QBs and several have seen their greatest success with it, but Mahomes had everything you look for; basically all the concerns about him were in relation to being in a college offense that had a history of artificially inflating stats. Allen looked like a stud in shorts, but had serious accuracy problems in college.

 

[OneLofaTatupu]

Man…I get down on him but, we certainly have a really, really good QB (*ducks the incoming frag*).

Just hope our new OC can get the line click-clackin.

Hell yeah. Give Geno more time for poor decisions

 

[pittpnthrs]

Not sure I agree with this. Allen was one of the biggest boom or bust QB prospects in recent memory and I think he would have failed in more places than Mahomes would have. Yes, the Reid system is beneficial to QBs and several have seen their greatest success with it, but Mahomes had everything you look for; basically all the concerns about him were in relation to being in a college offense that had a history of artificially inflating stats. Allen looked like a stud in shorts, but had serious accuracy problems in college.

Not only all of this, but Mahomes just keeps beating him.

 

[Seahawker]

Not only all of this, but Mahomes just keeps beating him.

 

[CalgaryFan05]

View attachment 69383View attachment 69384View attachment 69385

Right?

Can't stand Mahomes. Wouldn't bring him anywhere near the team. Didja even *see* the flopping 15 did in the playoffs. Barf.

Frank Ragnow - Center - Detroit Lions
Derrick Henry - RB - Baltimore Ravens
Saquon Barkley - RB - Philadelphia Eagles
Chris Lindstrom - Guard - Atlanta Falcons
Trent Williams - Tackle - San Francisco 49ers
Myles Garrett - DE - Cleveland Browns

Geno's serviceable under a hopefully better OC and some line upgrades.

And I picked six just because I could

Wife's vote: without hesitation on a surprise question: Bwagz!

And a surprise bonus pick: Whoever Mahome's Referee "whip" is. That dude knows how to get results!

 

[DarkVictory23]

I wanna say Mahomes but Josh Allen is atleast right there. Without Andy Reid, Mahomes career could be a lot different and he owes a lot of his success to his system. Allen has gotten even better Without Diggs being a distraction and has literally put the entire offense on his back and been great(Cook is very good RB in that offense too).

Other than QB, I'd go with a healthy Nick Bosa or TJ Watt. Elite pass rushers are extremely valuable.

I picked Allen specifically because it's 'current' player. 2022, Mahomes had one of the best seasons of a QB has ever had, but for two straight seasons he's been underwhelming.

Has he been good? Of course. But he's been nowhere near the conversation for MVP or anything else like it. It's not even been a suggestion or any sort of question that he's not in those convos.