Geno injury

[Natethegreat]

I can't process how dumb of a comment that is.

Processing is both yours and Genos problem.

 

[SoulfishHawk]

 

[SonicHawk]

Processing is both yours and Genos problem.

I have screenshotted 4/5 Geno INTs (the 4th qtr hail mary I'll skip).

You tell me where the bad decision is, you ignore the clear hold, you can stop talking like you know ball.

None of these are bad decisions.

 

[SoulfishHawk]

Bad decisions are quite common for Geno this season. No matter how many screen shots you provide. He's an average QB, who sometimes plays above average. His decision making is BAD in the red zone. THAT is unacceptable for a QB. It was bad enough he got lucky on the previous play in the red zone. He doubles down the very next play and throws ANOTHER pick in the end zone. At some point, the Geno Fanboys need to face reality. Dear god, it never ends.

 

[SonicHawk]

Bad decisions are quite common for Geno this season. No matter how many screen shots you provide. He's an average QB, who sometimes plays above average. His decision making is BAD in the red zone. THAT is unacceptable for a QB. It was bad enough he got lucky on the previous play in the red zone. He doubles down the very next play and throws ANOTHER pick in the end zone. At some point, the Geno Fanboys need to face reality. Dear god, it never ends.

I'm just arguing against bad decisions. I don't think Geno makes bad decisions as much as he's made bad throws.

Does that make me a Geno fanboy?

 

[SoulfishHawk]

Meh, we can agree to disagree on Geno. I don't feel like another timeout
And I do respect your opinion, and I have no issues with someone disagreeing with me. It's part of the deal.
It was slight sarcasm because Toffee was calling people Howell fanboys. Just a bad joke

 

[SonicHawk]

Meh, we can agree to disagree on Geno. I don't feel like another timeout

I heard you only get timeouts when you make a great point.

And I do respect your opinion, and I have no issues with someone disagreeing with me. It's part of the deal.
It was slight sarcasm because Toffee was calling people Howell fanboys. Just a bad joke

I'm definitely more defensive of Geno than most -- but that's mostly because Will Levis exists.

 

[Natethegreat]

I'm just arguing against bad decisions. I don't think Geno makes bad decisions as much as he's made bad throws.

Does that make me a Geno fanboy?

K, fair enough. By the way I think Geno is a good enough QB that needs better decision making to be really good. As in good enough for this team to win a super bowl.
That's what I see after watching him start for us since Russ.
He gets spastic at times and makes head scratching decisions too often. Including back breaking sacks in the end zone and sacks that take us out of field goal range.
It's not just the picks for me. I hope he gets better and the line certainly doesn't help.

 

[Sperrydogg]

Peyton Manning did not move around. I know now exactly how much you watched Peyton Manning. Quarterbacks have to be able to make plays from the pocket.

Running splits the field in half. Once Geno sprints left, he no longer has access to anyone on the right. A QB has to stay in the pocket if at all possible to maximize his options.

This old fused back grandpa moves better than geno

 

[SonicHawk]

K, fair enough. By the way I think Geno is a good enough QB that needs better decision making to be pretty good. As in good enough for this team to win a super bowl.
That's what I see after watching him start for us since Russ.
He gets spastic at times and makes head scratching decisions too often. Including back breaking sacks in the end zone and sacks that take us out of field goal range.
It's not just the picks for me. I hope he gets better and the line certainly doesn't help.

I've spent so much time in All 22 RZ that I didn't re-look at sacks. I'll spend some time there as well, his sack % is way up as well so is it him being a dumbshit or something else. Seems to me your hypothesis is more that but I don't have a solid opinion yet. There are only so many excuses for sacks though, so definitely leaning.

 

[Sperrydogg]

I'm just arguing against bad decisions. I don't think Geno makes bad decisions as much as he's made bad throws.

Does that make me a Geno fanboy?

I don’t think it’s the quantity of bad decisions (besides standing in the pocket like the British guardsman) it’s meltdowns in critical situations that lead to timing of bad decisions i.e. the red zone.

 

[Natethegreat]

I've spent so much time in All 22 RZ that I didn't re-look at sacks. I'll spend some time there as well, his sack % is way up as well so is it him being a dumbshit or something else. Seems to me your hypothesis is more that but I don't have a solid opinion yet.

I'm talking about being backed up in the end zone and then some bad sacks that take us out of field goal range or on the edge of range where he should have just gotten rid of the ball. He has done this multiple times this year.

 

[Sperrydogg]

You know I’ve held on to this story for awhile cause it’s about ping pong, but imma go for it. I used to play ping pong with my work crew every day after work and we were ultra competitive, we were all pretty good and each of us had some cool tricks, I had a wicked slicing serve, but this kid Kramer… he was the best, not by much but it was definitive, he had this slow curve shot that he could do, and he waited for the ping pong to get really deep, sometimes he would pick it right before it hit the floor and you couldn’t see where it was coming from until it hit the table and spun in the opposite direction. I might have beaten him 1/10 times, but every game came down to game point. I would have him right where I wanted but somehow he always dug down and found a way to pull out the W. I’m geno… I got close, a lot, but Kramer was Patrick and even when you thought you had him he had you….

Geno doesn’t have that dig down W, no curveball, every thing is textbook and a lot a times it looks right but when you get out in the wild you leave the textbook in the bag

 

[SonicHawk]

A fellow paddler, nice.

 

[Sperrydogg]

Or third down drive killing sacks after two beautiful throws to JSN and a good run by Charbs… throws plays where your like ok nice pocket… throw it geno, c’mon, THROW IT!!! Dammm

 

[Sperrydogg]

geno: can I get some blockers?
Grubb: we’re not gonna beat their pass rush so just stand there and take it…
Geno: OH, I got this!

 

[SoulfishHawk]

Or watching the clock run down to the last second. Snap the effin ball. It's maddening.

 

[Rat]

What happened on that pass before the INT? Got lucky that wasn't picked off.

 

[SoulfishHawk]

EXACTLY why everyone in my section was losing their sh**

It's one thing do to it once. Then he doubles down. He is a good QB, but my god he is maddening to watch.

 

[MontanaHawk05]

This old fused back grandpa moves better than geno

Ah, how predictable. He went and dug up THAT play.

Doesn't disprove what we know from his other 15,000 dropbacks. Peyton was famous for being a pocket quarterback.

And Geno DOES have wheels, especially impressive ones for his age. He's gotten national attention for it.

His problem is his red-zone decision-making, not his lack of mobility. I understand you need to vent, but there's plenty to criticise him for without making things up.