MontanaHawk05
Well-known member
- Joined
- May 1, 2009
- Messages
- 18,575
- Reaction score
- 1,510
[tweet]https://twitter.com/BradyHenderson/status/975792447803535360[/tweet]
rossob":3w0v72k1 said:Didn't he have a down year?
EverydayImRusselin":2cq9zmjo said:If you've seen the prices OL are fetching these days, it's a good deal.
Huh? Britt signed his extension before we drafted Pocic.pittpnthrs":3f8elomf said:Makes the Pocic pick look even worse. I still believe they only drafted him because they were afraid Britt was leaving.
SoulfishHawk":7nm5c4au said:Pretty early to Assume Pocic won't be a good lineman.
Jville":1q6sxyqs said:^^^
Getting the best 5 linemen on the field has been pretty much the norm around the NFL for decades. Posted objections are likely a reflection of the limits of an author's understanding. IMHO.
hawk45":28jyxaip said:Jville":28jyxaip said:^^^
Getting the best 5 linemen on the field has been pretty much the norm around the NFL for decades. Posted objections are likely a reflection of the limits of an author's understanding. IMHO.
The above is likely a reflection of the limits of the author's understanding of the post being responded to.
There is quite clearly a trade-off between versatility and aptitude/profile/match for a single position. Guards and Tackles have very different profiles. Get Hawknation2018 up in here to talk about the differences in athleticism, length, footwork, on and on.
Versatility is a much clearer virtue for backups, because they allow a single player to backfill multiple spots and because you are already accepting the less-than-optimal profile if you must use a backup. So the trade-off is easier to justify.
NFL teams do try to get the best 5 linemen out there, but that doesn't mean they don't balance that with not putting some squat, slow, guard-profiled player on the edge just because he's "the best lineman". It's only if he's "the best tackle" that you put him out there.
In other words, 12forlife was pretty much dead on in every point.
Later on he added, “Right now, Bobby is the fifth-best offensive lineman. He’s ascending and he’s getting better. He’s doing some nice things. The hard thing for someone like a Bobby Hart, a young offensive lineman is consistency. That’ll come. He’s working at it and doing a nice job in the classroom.” He also confirmed that Hart is the fifth lineman counting Marshall Newhouse. [urltargetblank]https://www.bigblueview.com/2016/11/4/13527846/ny-giants-philadelphia-eagles-mike-solari-bobby-hart[/urltargetblank]
There were calls for Beatty to move into the starting lineup after Flowers and Hart struggled in a Week 5 loss to the Packers, but the Giants didn't make any changes.
"The thing about Green Bay, we didn't play well. It's something we have to improve on in that situation," offensive line coach Mike Solari said. "But right now, Bobby is the fifth-best offensive lineman. He's ascending, he's getting better, he's doing some nice things. The hard thing for somebody like a Bobby Hart, a young offensive lineman, is consistency. And that will come." [urltargetblank]http://www.nj.com/giants/index.ssf/2016/11/why_isnt_giants_will_beatty_playing_ol_coach_mike.html[/urltargetblank]