Breda Report: The Vilification of Russell Wilson

AROS

Administrator
Administrator
Moderator
Joined
Feb 23, 2007
Messages
20,563
Reaction score
11,845
Location
Astoria, OR
Back in 2012, Russell Wilson walked into the away team's tunnel after a heart-daggering loss to the Atlanta Falcons in the divisional round of the playoffs. This was a game that any player and coach for the Seahawks knew they should have won. Coach Pete Carroll has said on numerous occasions that he didn't get "100 steps..." or so into the tunnel before Russell came up to him and said in paraphrase: "Coach, we are going to win the Super Bowl next year."

It was a remarkable insight and a hint of presumptuousness that is rare for a rookie QB.

That Super Bowl played in New Orleans just weeks later was attended by one Russell Wilson. Rumor has it he showed up early, walked the field and observed the stretching routines of the 49ers and Ravens for one simple reason; He wanted to visualize what it looked like to be in the Super Bowl. He took it in, every moment, observing what he would always say for years to come, no matter the importance of the game, the field is still just "53.3 yards wide and 100 yards long" emphasizing what was the central paradigm of Pete Carroll which is to not treat any game like it's more important than any other. In the end, it's just football. That way you are neutral in your collective emotions for any game, great or small.

We all know what was to become of the next season when Russell and the LOB enjoyed the first Championship in team history with a massive exclamation mark against which was at the time the most prolific offense in the history of the NFL.

To truncate the story, some very important markers changed Russell. His marriage to the lukewarm pop star Ciara and the infamous ending to Super Bowl 49 against the Patriots that is still debated feverishly to this day.

These elements simply changed the man.

Somewhere in this general timeline, Russell went from "no time to sleep" to living and breathing for his "brand" and "legacy". Suddenly, perfume endorsements and front cover magazine shots (appearing naked from the waist up on a horse) seemed to be the new focus. Not that he stopped football altogether but it became a clear and concise directive to build his self-perceived brand. This became a fracture to the health of the locker room, which is one of the most underrated aspects of a Championship-caliber team.

As the years rolled on it became more and more clear that that elusive second ring was existentially floating away like the volleyball ironically named "Wilson" in Tom Hank's movie Castaway.

The ugly narrative of Russ not being "black enough" compiled with his clear separation from his teammates and being coddled by Pete Carroll further strengthened the vast cavernous divide. Suddenly, the upstart quarterback became inflamed by desire for ego-centric pursuits completing the tragic end to what could have been a - dare we say - dynasty.

We all know how the story ends. Russell demanded more control of the offense so he could "cook". It worked brilliantly, until it didn't. Allegedly he asked ownership to remove Pete and John so he could basically run the team as he saw fit. He ended up shipped to Denver and received his just desserts.

Still, regardless of career trajectory, acute tone-deafness and ego-driven pursuits, it seems somehow cruel how he is now received by the average fan. Especially Seahawks fans. Somehow, like magic, all the years that he was a magician on the field, creating victories from the mouth of defeat, have been erased from the memories of many. All that seems to matter now is the breakup and his apparent demise.

He's become a caricature. Forgotten is his ability to lead his men into battle ("Why not us?!"), his earnest desire to help others and ultimately his seemingly genuine desire to be a decent human being.

Russell's relentless passion to win MVP or another ring may or may not ever come to light (and the ultimate destination of Canton is seemingly more and more distant by the day).

Whether it's a lesson in human condition or the perpetual pursuit of success becomes the same side of a shiny coin.

Russell Wilson for all of his success and failures, is a mirror to all of us. We all have our moments of glory within our lives, as well as the shadows of regret we all wish to forget.

In the end, what none of us can deny, is that he's one of us.

Human.
 

hawkfan68

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 3, 2007
Messages
10,234
Reaction score
2,102
Location
Sammamish, WA
Fantastic write-up, Aros. IIRC, Superbowl 47 (played in 2012-13 season - Russell's rookie year) was the 49ers vs. Ravens not Giants and Patriots.
 
OP
OP
AROS

AROS

Administrator
Administrator
Moderator
Joined
Feb 23, 2007
Messages
20,563
Reaction score
11,845
Location
Astoria, OR
Fantastic write-up, Aros. IIRC, Superbowl 47 (played in 2012-13 season - Russell's rookie year) was the 49ers vs. Ravens not Giants and Patriots.

Thanks! Ooops, let me revise...
 

GemCity

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 20, 2022
Messages
3,185
Reaction score
3,659
Back in 2012, Russell Wilson walked into the away team's tunnel after a heart-daggering loss to the Atlanta Falcons in the divisional round of the playoffs. This was a game that any player and coach for the Seahawks new they should have won. Coach Pete Carroll has said on numerous occasions that he didn't get "100 steps..." or so into the tunnel before Russell came up to him and said in paraphrase: "Coach, we are going to win the Super Bowl next year."

It was a remarkable insight and a hint of presumptuousness that is rare for a rookie QB.

That Super Bowl played in New Orleans just weeks later was attended by one Russell Wilson. Rumor has it he showed up early, walked the field and observed the stretching routines of the Giants and Patriots for one simple reason; He wanted to visualize what it looked like to be in the Super Bowl. He took it in, every moment, observing what he would always say for years to come, no matter the importance of the game, the field is still just "53.3 yards wide and 100 yards long" emphasizing what was the central paradigm of Pete Carroll which is to not treat any game like it's more important than any other. In the end, it's just football. That way you are neutral in your collective emotions for any game, great or small.

We all know what was to become of the next season when Russell and the LOB enjoyed the first Championship in team history with a massive exclamation mark against which was at the time the most prolific offense in the history of the NFL.

To truncate the story, some very important markers changed Russell. His marriage to the lukewarm pop star Ciara and the infamous ending to Super Bowl 49 against the Patriots that is still debated feverishly to this day.

These elements simply changed the man.

Somewhere in this general timeline, Russell went from "no time to sleep" to living and breathing for his "brand" and "legacy". Suddenly, perfume endorsements and front cover magazine shots (appearing naked from the waist up on a horse) seemed to be the new focus. Not that he stopped football altogether but it became a clear and concise directive to build his self-perceived brand. This became a fracture to the health of the locker room, which is one of the most underrated aspects of a Championship-caliber team.

As the years rolled on it became more and more clear that that elusive second ring was existentially floating away like the volleyball ironically called "Wilson" in Tom Hank's movie Castaway.

The ugly narrative of Russ not being "black enough" compiled with his clear separation from his teammates and being coddled by Pete Carroll further strengthened the vast cavernous divide. Suddenly, the upstart quarterback became inflamed by the desire for ego-centric pursuits completing the tragic end to what could have been a - dare we say - dynasty.

We all know how the story ends. Russell demanded more control of the offense so he could "cook". It worked brilliantly, until it didn't. Allegedly he asked ownership to remove Pete and John so he could basically run the team as he saw fit. He ended up shipped to Denver and received his just desserts.

Still, regardless of career trajectory, acute tone-deafness and ego-driven pursuits, it seems somehow cruel how he is received by the average fan. Especially Seahawks fans. Somehow, like magic, all the years that he was a magician on the field, creating victories from the mouth of defeat, have been erased by many. All that seems to matter now is the breakup and his apparent demise.

He's become a caricature. Forgotten is his ability to lead his men into battle ("Why not us?!"), his earnest desire to help others and ultimately to try to be a decent human being.

Russell's desire to win MVP or another ring may or may not ever come to light.

Whether it's a lesson in human condition or the relentless pursuit of success becomes the same side of a shiny coin.

Russell Wilson for all of his success and failures, is a mirror to all of us. We all have our moments of glory within our lives, as well as the shadows of regret we all wish to forget.

In the end, what none of us can deny, he's one of us.

Human.
Well done!!! Thank you for sharing!!
 

Kamcussionator

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 13, 2014
Messages
561
Reaction score
897
Location
San Diego, CA
Nice bit of prose, however the mistake that Wilson made -- that is the source of all his current disdain -- is that he lost his humility. He put himself above his team, his coaches, and his fan base.

Had he apologized for the SB interception, continued to play within the offense and take coaching, or showed any kind of effort to "protect the team" instead of his own commercial interests; he would have been forgiven for being human. Instead, he will be remembered as a limited quarterback that squandered our window for greatness (per the LOB) in attempt to gain personal glory.
 

chris98251

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 27, 2007
Messages
40,236
Reaction score
2,483
Location
Roy Wa.
I think after his divorce and being a diligent worker wanting success he met Ciara, and that was the beginning of the end. Or maybe met her first and that could have been the start of his break up and divorce, either way, he evolved from having that IT factor and dynamic QB, to having that ICK factor and becoming phony and self absorbed.

He tried to reinvent himself as a Hollywood / Music / Celebrity type, he not in front of the fans but behind the scenes started acting like a actor or musician that in those industries are impossible to work with by many, Brando, Charlie Sheen and Coppola are three in Hollywood that kind of revolve around that stigma, in music there are many from Gene Simmons, Madonna, and others that have to have it their way or no way. When your at the top looking down you can get away with that for a while, trouble is, Russell Wilson I think believed he was the reason we won, we as fans know he was a missing piece amongst other pieces. The defense was the fire, Lynch the Match, Wilson was the table setter and server, he was never the cook however, that was Pete and John.
 

knownone

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 7, 2010
Messages
5,805
Reaction score
2,953
Russell did not change much. He has always been the same guy. Time and success have a way of revealing who people truly are.

Watch interviews of Russ in college or his rookie season. He was fairly open about wanting to be some combination of Derek Jeder, Kobe Bryant, and Jay-Z, which makes perfect sense, given his age. He was always conscious of himself as a brand, trying to pivot his image from how fans perceived him—a nerdy robot—to how he wanted to be perceived. That's why he did so few local interviews after his rookie season.

Russell's change being a conscious choice from the start is why some fans still malign him today. Because, in hindsight (right or wrong), everything points to Russ putting himself first as the catalyst for the team's eventual demise. He then cemented that legacy by going after a genuinely authentic figure—Pete Carroll—and failing spectacularly in the process.

Russ made his bed. He learned the hard lesson that legacy is not something you can control. If any moral is to be derived from his situation, it's that.
 
OP
OP
AROS

AROS

Administrator
Administrator
Moderator
Joined
Feb 23, 2007
Messages
20,563
Reaction score
11,845
Location
Astoria, OR
Russell did not change much. He has always been the same guy. Time and success have a way of revealing who people truly are.

Watch interviews of Russ in college or his rookie season. He was fairly open about wanting to be some combination of Derek Jeder, Kobe Bryant, and Jay-Z, which makes perfect sense, given his age. He was always conscious of himself as a brand, trying to pivot his image from how fans perceived him—a nerdy robot—to how he wanted to be perceived. That's why he did so few local interviews after his rookie season.

Russell's change being a conscious choice from the start is why some fans still malign him today. Because, in hindsight (right or wrong), everything points to Russ putting himself first as the catalyst for the team's eventual demise. He then cemented that legacy by going after a genuinely authentic figure—Pete Carroll—and failing spectacularly in the process.

Russ made his bed. He learned the hard lesson that legacy is not something you can control. If any moral is to be derived from his situation, it's that.

All-in-all I agree with the tenor of your post. I do agree he was open about who he was - after all, he was a robotic invention largely influenced by his father - but there most definitely was a shift in his character from Ciara onward. Now I am not so hollow to suggest "It's Ciara's fault!!" however the change in his approach became clearer once he married her.

Not to be argumentative in the least but I disagree that legacy is not something you can control. To my mind it certainly IS something you can control in your actions, words, deeds and talent on the field.
 

IndyHawk

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 19, 2013
Messages
8,617
Reaction score
2,260
I like your reports Todd..
I don't care for Me3 and it's not easy trying to do a write up on him
but you tried and gave it a good shot.
I hope you do others like Easley,Mudbone,Bam Bam,Big Walt or even Pete.
 

Pandion Haliaetus

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 16, 2013
Messages
3,950
Reaction score
964
The last two sentences in the OP…

Do you think he finally “bicentennial man’d” himself?
 

BlueTalon

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 3, 2007
Messages
9,215
Reaction score
2,037
Location
Eastern Washington
I liked him when he was likeable. Then he became unlikeable. Whether that was because he changed, or whether he's still the same as he always was but just dropped the likeable facade, doesn't really make a difference to me.

I really enjoyed watching him faceplant in Denver. I hope to see very much more of that in Pittstink.
 

Pandion Haliaetus

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 16, 2013
Messages
3,950
Reaction score
964
I liked him when he was likeable. Then he became unlikeable. Whether that was because he changed, or whether he's still the same as he always was but just dropped the likeable facade, doesn't really make a difference to me.

I really enjoyed watching him faceplant in Denver. I hope to see very much more of that in Pittstink.

Well, considering he low key is going to teams us fans kind of don’t really like. And every team he has left, a lot of high profile ex-players of those teams that have a media presence more or less continue to bash him this time with Schlereth and Sharpe holding that candle, I consider that he is still in fact rather unlikeable maybe more so than current Jets Oline coach, Keith Carter (whom in my deep dive of Tomlinson with the Jets, uncovered that a lot of his ex-players and current players might hate him).
 

RiverDog

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 8, 2013
Messages
5,943
Reaction score
3,695
Location
Kennewick, WA
Back in 2012, Russell Wilson walked into the away team's tunnel after a heart-daggering loss to the Atlanta Falcons in the divisional round of the playoffs. This was a game that any player and coach for the Seahawks knew they should have won. Coach Pete Carroll has said on numerous occasions that he didn't get "100 steps..." or so into the tunnel before Russell came up to him and said in paraphrase: "Coach, we are going to win the Super Bowl next year."

It was a remarkable insight and a hint of presumptuousness that is rare for a rookie QB.

That Super Bowl played in New Orleans just weeks later was attended by one Russell Wilson. Rumor has it he showed up early, walked the field and observed the stretching routines of the 49ers and Ravens for one simple reason; He wanted to visualize what it looked like to be in the Super Bowl. He took it in, every moment, observing what he would always say for years to come, no matter the importance of the game, the field is still just "53.3 yards wide and 100 yards long" emphasizing what was the central paradigm of Pete Carroll which is to not treat any game like it's more important than any other. In the end, it's just football. That way you are neutral in your collective emotions for any game, great or small.

We all know what was to become of the next season when Russell and the LOB enjoyed the first Championship in team history with a massive exclamation mark against which was at the time the most prolific offense in the history of the NFL.

To truncate the story, some very important markers changed Russell. His marriage to the lukewarm pop star Ciara and the infamous ending to Super Bowl 49 against the Patriots that is still debated feverishly to this day.

These elements simply changed the man.

Somewhere in this general timeline, Russell went from "no time to sleep" to living and breathing for his "brand" and "legacy". Suddenly, perfume endorsements and front cover magazine shots (appearing naked from the waist up on a horse) seemed to be the new focus. Not that he stopped football altogether but it became a clear and concise directive to build his self-perceived brand. This became a fracture to the health of the locker room, which is one of the most underrated aspects of a Championship-caliber team.

As the years rolled on it became more and more clear that that elusive second ring was existentially floating away like the volleyball ironically named "Wilson" in Tom Hank's movie Castaway.

The ugly narrative of Russ not being "black enough" compiled with his clear separation from his teammates and being coddled by Pete Carroll further strengthened the vast cavernous divide. Suddenly, the upstart quarterback became inflamed by desire for ego-centric pursuits completing the tragic end to what could have been a - dare we say - dynasty.

We all know how the story ends. Russell demanded more control of the offense so he could "cook". It worked brilliantly, until it didn't. Allegedly he asked ownership to remove Pete and John so he could basically run the team as he saw fit. He ended up shipped to Denver and received his just desserts.

Still, regardless of career trajectory, acute tone-deafness and ego-driven pursuits, it seems somehow cruel how he is now received by the average fan. Especially Seahawks fans. Somehow, like magic, all the years that he was a magician on the field, creating victories from the mouth of defeat, have been erased from the memories of many. All that seems to matter now is the breakup and his apparent demise.

He's become a caricature. Forgotten is his ability to lead his men into battle ("Why not us?!"), his earnest desire to help others and ultimately his seemingly genuine desire to be a decent human being.

Russell's relentless passion to win MVP or another ring may or may not ever come to light (and the ultimate destination of Canton is seemingly more and more distant by the day).

Whether it's a lesson in human condition or the perpetual pursuit of success becomes the same side of a shiny coin.

Russell Wilson for all of his success and failures, is a mirror to all of us. We all have our moments of glory within our lives, as well as the shadows of regret we all wish to forget.

In the end, what none of us can deny, is that he's one of us.

Human.
Excellent summation, @AROS! Although I will add that this metamorphosis of Russell's persona occurred very gradually and was not apparent to most of us for quite some time. For myself, I think I became aware of it about a year or two before the trade, during the "Let Russ Cook" and "I'm Getting Hit Too Much" era.

The other thing is that I'd like to add my weight to is your very last word: Human. The man is not the Devil reincarnated. There are a lot worse people in this world than Russell Wilson. I certainly wouldn't want to contrast my own flaws to those of Russell's. Zip up your fly, RD!
 
Last edited:
Top