Who is more important to this franchise...

Football gods willing, we will have the Wilson/Carroll tandem for years to come but if not, who is more important to this franchise: Wilson or Carroll?
Clearly Wilson is a franchise QB and 1 or 2 years (or one super bowl win) away from the "elite" tag. Carroll's knowledge of the game and the atmosphere that he has fostered are almost beyond unique.

My gut wants to say Wilson but I think that's only because PC is an older coach and I think that he will likely retire before RW. Unfortunately, this has nothing to do with their value to the team and is tainting my ability to look at them objectively.

What do you guys think? Who is more important to this team down the road, DangerRuss or The Silver Fox?

Can't choose. This league is all about the combo.

WHY would you post some gutwrenching thing like this right after one of our greatest victories ever?

I don't get it...

#3. If you aint got a QB, you aint got nothing.

Trenchbroom":106su7yb said:

WHY would you post some gutwrenching thing like this right after one of our greatest victories ever?

I don't get it...

Click to expand...

THIS

We've seen Pete with Tarvaris and Hasslebeck... so I'm going with Wilson. Oh and this thread sucks

Caroll.. He could find us another quarterback

definitely wont be another russ, but still

-The Glove-":1r6ivpct said:

We've seen Pete with Tarvaris and Hasslebeck... so I'm going with Wilson. Oh and this thread sucks

Click to expand...

:13:

Would you rather give up your blood or your air?

JSeahawks":1dx77356 said:

#3. If you aint got a QB, you aint got nothing.

Click to expand...

:13: (and yeah, ugly thread dude)

Pstark3":36ojcwp7 said:

Caroll.. He could find us another quarterback

definitely wont be another russ, but still

Click to expand...

A ridiculous post. I don't think you realize that Russell is that once in a lifetime QB we've been waiting for. Just wait. Eventually November 29th will be known as Christmas to all Hawk fans around the world.

Seattle angstiness at it's best. Everything is wonderful, it must be too good. How can I poop on it?

So much stupid in one thread, that being said #3, he actually plays the game.

I would never had said so two years ago..but its Carroll and his staff. He has a program, he has his ideas and is taking a different approach to football. Id would slit my wrists if we lost Wilson..but if I had to choose..

Scottemojo":2oku2oaq said:

Seattle angstiness at it's best. Everything is wonderful, it must be too good. How can I poop on it?

Click to expand...

Angst? Please! Angst is "We're screwed when we lose one of these guys". This is a legitimate question. What's more important a strong coach with a winning philosophy or a potentially elite franchise QB?

This has been the best of my 33 years being a Hawks fan and I'm enjoying the hell out of it. No one is trying to poo in your Cheerios, Scotte.

Wilson. Sorry I love Carroll but Wilsons don't come around too often.

brimsalabim":3lsyfoul said:

Would you rather give up your blood or your air?

Click to expand...

Best answer.

This is a TEAM, it is not about individuals.

OrFan":1zyv73ne said:

brimsalabim":1zyv73ne said:

Would you rather give up your blood or your air?

Click to expand...

Best answer.

This is a TEAM, it is not about individuals.

Click to expand...

Except a team is only as strongest as your weakest link, and QB is the most important position on the field, and Fa QBs only come around evey so often Its a no brainer RW.