NINEster":11oyf42k said:rideaducati":11oyf42k said:I was judging the values based on history of both players. Keep hoping for different results in the future. :th2thumbs:
If I judged both QBs on their playoff performances, I could make a very strong argument that the debate is STILL unsettled, maybe even tilted towards Kaepernick.
I'm sure Kaepernick would love to have played in a few more home playoff games (only *1* for him, with only *2* road games for Wilson), and perhaps anything but a 3 TD deficit after SB halftime would have been nice compared to Wilson not having to throw a TD pass until the game was already in the bag for the Hawks.
Despite all of this, Kap has played pretty damn well in the playoffs. His two rematch games in 2013 against Carolina and Seattle were easily better than the regular season matchups. His 2012 postseason he carried the team.
By the Hawks argument that Wilson just wins, you gotta put Kap above Cam Newton, Andy Dalton, even Andrew Luck because guess what compared to those guys, KAP WINS.
But naturally that argument won't fly here because it would contradict the hate for Kap.
So what is it?
Hmm lets see
Kap playoff stats
94 comp, 162 att, 1374 yards ,58% compl, 8.48 ypa, 7 tds 5 ints, 87.5 Qb rating
Wilson playoff stats
123 comp, 202 att, 1820 yards, 61% compl, 9 ypa, 12 tds, 6 ints, 98.1 qb rating
Hmm yeah pretty setteled to me. Forgetting yards, 3 points higher on comp %, over 10 in Qb rating, .5 more ypa, .6 more td/int meaning wilson is 2/1 kap 1.4/1 yeah it is settled Wilson wins enough said