Popeyejones
Active member
- Joined
- Aug 20, 2013
- Messages
- 5,525
- Reaction score
- 0
freezefail":3i4rguz4 said:TaterHawk":3i4rguz4 said:It's a sad reflection of the 9ers orginization. They made a punk kid the leader because he can run. IQ is the most important factor in QB play. I've said it before..he is not smart, and they will pay for it. Smith is leading KC to what will be an amazing season. All is as it should be.
The guy got a 4.0 at nevada state, what you get at your college?
People will say "Yeah, at Nevada State" which I don't think is fair, but I also don't think we should take elite college football player's GPAs too seriously at all.
That said if one wants to assert that "IQ is the most important factor in QB play" (as TaterHawk does, and I strongly, strongly disagree with, IIRC there's some correlation but not overwhelming, and IIRC it's more of a threshold effect than a raw score thing) the Wonderlic is an IQ test, so we actually know players' IQs.
Kaepernick scored a 37 on the Wonderlic which puts him in the 98th percentile for the general population, and also qualifies him for Mensa (they accept the Wonderlic, column W here: http://goo.gl/OO7bjk)*. Russel Wilson scored a 28; on an IQ test his IQ is much lower. That said, I think this means squat, but if one wants to assert that IQ is incredibly important in QB play and that's what makes Kap a bad quarterback, that is just a bad argument (IMO it doesn't matter) on top of a horrible argument (just factually inaccurate about Kap's IQ).
*(also worth just throwing it out there that I think Mensa is a stupid organization, and I don't put too much stock in IQ tests for a host of reasons; the flynn effect, multiple intelligences, the complete and total train wreck of causality when trying to make nature or nurture arguments, etc.)