Cowpokes @ Igles

[Fade]

Quinn is man.

 

[DarkVictory23]

I've never been a fan of how Pete handles the game between the whistles but if there is any professional coach that is worse, it's definitely Mike McCarthy.

How the heck do you not challenge that fourth down ruling?

 

[Maelstrom787]

I've never been a fan of how Pete handles the game between the whistles but if there is any professional coach that is worse, it's definitely Mike McCarthy.

How the heck do you not challenge that fourth down ruling?

Pete's actually surprisingly typical with a lot of his challenges and in-game decisions, from my perspective. There are some real doozies all around the NFL weekly.

 

[Fade]

The Cooper Rush hype train has come to an end. A big hit to those who think QB is nigh plug 'n play.

Dak can't get back soon enough for them.

 

[DarkVictory23]

Pete's actually surprisingly typical with a lot of his challenges and in-game decisions, from my perspective. There are some real doozies all around the NFL weekly.

Eh, still don't think Pete's good at game management but I believe for sure there are other coaches that are as bad (or worse, as McCarthy is).

 

[bigskydoc]

Do I have to watch this? No, in fact, I don't.

 

[Fade]

Pete's actually surprisingly typical with a lot of his challenges and in-game decisions, from my perspective. There are some real doozies all around the NFL weekly.

Tacitly admitting Pete is bad at game management, but it is okay because look at the rest of the league is not a good look for Pete.

I need to do a deep dive on this one of these days, ranking all 32 HCs on game management. I'd be surprised if Peter didn't finish bottom 8 along with Mike McCarthy, but who knows maybe he is middle of the pack.

I do know he burns a lot of timeouts, doesn't/does challenge at the wrong times, and luvs 2 punt when he should go for it.

I watch a lot of other teams and not many come to mind being worse than Carroll in this area.

 

[Maelstrom787]

Tacitly admitting Pete is bad at game management, but it is okay because look at the rest of the league is not a good look for Pete.

I need to do a deep dive on this one of these days, ranking all 32 HCs on game management. I'd be surprised if Peter didn't finish bottom 8 along with Mike McCarthy, but who knows maybe he is middle of the pack.

I do know he burns a lot of timeouts, doesn't/does challenge at the wrong times, and luvs 2 punt when he should go for it.

I watch a lot of other teams and not many come to mind being worse than Carroll in this area.

Oh, a deep dive? Cool, I'll give you a starting point on the challenge front.

Over Pete's tenure, as of late 2020, he was actually above average in terms of percentage of challenges won. 12th in the league.

The best and worst of the NFL coach’s challenge

Most coaches aren’t very good second guessing referees, but two of the best were recent coaches in Buffalo

www.rochesterfirst.com

Calling a coach fairly average at game management is "tacitly admitting they're bad at game management." It's measuring their performance in context, against their peers.

 

[Maelstrom787]

Dan Quinn's Cowboys defense dropped Parsons in coverage there and almost came away with a pick six. It ain't always bad, folks. There's a reason why everyone does it.

 

[LeaveLynchAlone]

Tacitly admitting Pete is bad at game management, but it is okay because look at the rest of the league is not a good look for Pete.

I need to do a deep dive on this one of these days, ranking all 32 HCs on game management. I'd be surprised if Peter didn't finish bottom 8 along with Mike McCarthy, but who knows maybe he is middle of the pack.

I do know he burns a lot of timeouts, doesn't/does challenge at the wrong times, and luvs 2 punt when he should go for it.

I watch a lot of other teams and not many come to mind being worse than Carroll in this area.

I can guarantee you will rank Pete at/near the bottom, but it won't have anything to do with reality.

Am I prescient? Of course not, you are just too easy to read before you even make your case.

 

[Fade]

Mike McCarthy with the tremendous halftime adjusments.

 

[BASF]

Anyone who doesn't see that Carroll uses his challenges to pause momentum changes does not know football. They may see it from an intellectual stand point, but don't get the emotions of it. Perhaps they never played the game. How many times have football fans see a turnover or big defensive stop that leads to a score almost immediately? That huge emotional swing plays a big part in it and the challenge takes some of that emotion and lets it bleed out over the several minutes that the refs take while conferring.

 

[IndyHawk]

When Fade call's Pete "Peter"... He's ruminating too much.

 

[Maelstrom787]

When Fade call's Pete "Peter"... He's ruminating too much.

Poominating

 

[ivotuk]

Anyone who doesn't see that Carroll uses his challenges to pause momentum changes does not know football. They may see it from an intellectual stand point, but don't get the emotions of it. Perhaps they never played the game. How many times have football fans see a turnover or big defensive stop that leads to a score almost immediately? That huge emotional swing plays a big part in it and the challenge takes some of that emotion and lets it bleed out over the several minutes that the refs take while conferring.

\
This is Fact. When the other team is taking off, and our defense is getting beat up, Pete will throw a flag to slow things down and hope he gets lucky. Challenge flags have more value than just challenging a play call.

 

[Maelstrom787]

\
This is Fact. When the other team is taking off, and our defense is getting beat up, Pete will throw a flag to slow things down and hope he gets lucky. Challenge flags have more value than just challenging a play call.

And even still, Carroll's challenge win rate is higher than average. I can't get behind the challenge criticisms at all.