I am guessing that Ware is a better runner than Robinson. His blocking in college was excellent but whether it is good enough for a Seahawk team with championship aspirations is an open question. If his blocking ability is at least close to Robinson's, Pete Carroll would have no qualms cutting Robinson. Remember, one of Carroll's guiding principles is "Always compete," and he is very open to new or younger players winning positions from veterans. Michael Robinson will not be excused from competeting just because he is a well-liked veteran and has been a valuable team member in the past.
In this salary-cap world, there isn't much room for emotion or loyalty. We, as fans, can be as sentimental as we want -- in fact, being emotional and illogical is part of our job description -- but the Seahawks front office must be cold and calculating in their decision making.
With the salary cap, value per dollar per player must be maximized, but the calculation of value is not straightforward.
Robinson's age (30), salary ($2.5 million this season) and contract situation (unrestricted free agent after this season) will play into the decision.
Robinson's experience and leadership contribute to his value, but the leadership might have also hurt him. Last year, right about this time, the Hawks were penalized a couple OTA sessions and a workout because the NFL said they were scrimmaging too hard. Someone had reported them to the NFL. Pete Carroll was not amused, especially after his recent experience with rules infractions at USC. The culprit who turned them in was almost surely Michael Robinson, the Seahawk player rep who was a great advocate of controlling off-season workouts and practices so that players had time to develop other careers for after their NFL days were over. If it was him, you have to respect him for treating his duties as player rep seriously, but you'd think it would be better to go to Carroll to discuss it privately first.
I have no idea what factors will play into the Seahawk decision. Like most fans, I like Michael Robinson and feel a sense of loyalty. I would love to see him back, but I hope the front office does their job, looks at the numbers and makes a cold decision if necessary. Certainly, when it comes down to it and if Ware is capable, the Seahawks should, probably towards the end of pre-season,renegotiate Robinson's salary for 2013 and tack on one or two unguaranteed years. If an organization is not capable of operating this way, they cannot have a good team for very long.
.