Pick your QB

Blind Stat QB Test. Who would you choose? (No looking it up)

  • QB1: 2 year starter 61.9 comp% 4773 pass yards 30 tds 17 ints -150 rush yards 3 rush td

  • QB2: 2.5 year starter 63.5% comp 11,252 pass yards 93 tds 29 ints 820 rush yards 22 rush td

  • QB3: 2 year starter 64.3% comp 6016 pass yards 45 tds 20 ints 1577 rush yards 33 rush td

  • QB4: 2 year starter 56.2% comp 44 tds 5066 pass yards 21 ints 767 rush yards 12 rush td 1 td rec

  • QB5: 4 year starter 60.9% comp 11,720 pass yard 109 tds 30 ints 1421 rush yards 23 rush tds 1 rec td

  • QB6: 3 year starter 57% comp 9043 pass yards 69 tds 27 ints 4132 rush yards 50 rush tds


Results are only viewable after voting.

glenwo2

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 12, 2025
Messages
563
Reaction score
519
Are all the QB stats from College?

Or did you put Milroe's College stats on the same level as those other NFL QB's NFL stats?

'Cause College and the Pros are vastly different.
 

Hollandhawk

Well-known member
Joined
May 9, 2009
Messages
1,036
Reaction score
957
Are all the QB stats from College?

Or did you put Milroe's College stats on the same level as those other NFL QB's NFL stats?

'Cause College and the Pros are vastly different.
Well since QB1 is Tom Brady, who started a few more years in the NFL than 2, I'd say these are college stats:).
 
Last edited:
OP
OP
Sprfunk

Sprfunk

Active member
Joined
Feb 9, 2010
Messages
968
Reaction score
223
Are all the QB stats from College?

Or did you put Milroe's College stats on the same level as those other NFL QB's NFL stats?

'Cause College and the Pros are vastly didifferent.
Yes, they are all college stats. The point was to see how Milroe's college numbers stacked against some of the best NFL players.

The reason for that was I wanted to show that there is an idea that Milroe cannot throw, and I believed it. I figured he would have a 50% completion percentage from the narrative. However I see much more upside in comparison to others.

It's very true that college numbers don't equate to NFL success. However poor college numbers the FAR majority of the time Equate to failing. For instance when people draft on potential alone.
 
OP
OP
Sprfunk

Sprfunk

Active member
Joined
Feb 9, 2010
Messages
968
Reaction score
223
3 yr starter 63.8% comp 10,283 pass yards 92 TDs 23 INTs 1009 rushing yards 3 rushing TDs

That's Sam Howell
We should have drafted that guy! Lol

Washington probably ruined him. He was a good prospect, and with protection and a good team he could have been different.

Grubb didn't do him and favors also.
 

Double Tribble

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 16, 2012
Messages
2,272
Reaction score
1,883
It is a shame we didn't get to develop him further, but I'll still take Milroe. Much higher upside long term. I hope.
 

Latest posts

Top