Krieg's list
New member
- Joined
- Oct 21, 2014
- Messages
- 50
- Reaction score
- 0
Still trying to figure out how you made this thread without including Christine Michael. Hell, he should've been the impetus behind it.
Hawkfan77":2aaiakfr said:And the funny thing is he was still a full time starter, who is netting us a likely 5th round comp pick next yearHasselbeck":2aaiakfr said:So of those 4 only Carp was a major let down. JS is batting .750
Am I missing something?
seabowl":tgk7ohe0 said:Carpenter
Irvin
Michael
P Rich
Frank Clark (if he hasn't already been arrested since his selection)
Nope, the JS regime is very good at drafting. It's nice cherry picking thoughTwilightError":1o1ufk9f said:seabowl":1o1ufk9f said:Carpenter
Irvin
Michael
P Rich
Frank Clark (if he hasn't already been arrested since his selection)
Fixed it for you. But it does not change the result...
Hawks46":274o6xoz said:Hawkfan77":274o6xoz said:Hasselbeck":274o6xoz said:I think there's some disconnect over Carpenter. We drated him as a Tackle, and in that he failed. Some people look at that as a failed draft pick and that's that. The reason Tackles are so highly valued in the draft (besides the importance of the position) is that if they don't work out, most times you can slide them inside and they do well as a Guard. It's a safety valve most positions just don't have.
I think they wanted to try Carpenter at Tackle (don't ask me why....his troubles with his weight were incredibly evident), but knew he could play Guard. So yea, in the perspective of drafting him to play Tackle, he's a flop. He was serviceable at Guard though, so the player himself wasn't a flop.
Using our pick on Graham this year was brilliant, especially after watching the draft.
Hawkfan77":3jrerzwi said:Nope, the JS regime is very good at drafting. It's nice cherry picking thoughTwilightError":3jrerzwi said:seabowl":3jrerzwi said:Carpenter
Irvin
Michael
P Rich
Frank Clark (if he hasn't already been arrested since his selection)
Fixed it for you. But it does not change the result...
Overseasfan":3vo4f3hz said:It's really convenient for you that you left out the first draft Carroll did. In the 2010 draft we got Okung (Pro-Bowl LT) and Thomas (All-Pro FS), hard to get better than that.
To sum it up, I have no problem with how the Hawks draft at all.