More successful NFL career, Dart or Sanders?

[toffee]

Who will enjoy a more successful career in NFL?

 

[SoulfishHawk]

I voted Dart. Let me guess, that's make me a hater and/or somehow racist

 

[toffee]

I voted Dart. Let me guess, that's make me a hater and/or somehow racist

I also voted for Dart, but for non-football reasons, he is an alum, and I love me some Rebels.

 

[James in PA]

That's like comparing Malik Willis and Desmond Ridder.

 

[Torc]

Well, Dart is going to spend his rookie year on the bench behind two experienced veterans. A year to learn, watch film of his actual offense, and run it in practice (albeit with probably limited reps). That's the ideal for any rookie with RARE exceptions.

Sanders is going to be competing in training camp with Flacco, Pickett and fellow draftee Dillon Gabriel. According to Deion, Shedeur is the best QB on their roster. I think his career depends on whether the coaching staff agrees with that assessment.

 

[SonicHawk]

Dart sucks

 

[toffee]

According to Deion, Shedeur is the best QB on their roster. I think his career depends on whether the coaching staff agrees with that assessment.

Deion is the gift that keeps on giving. HC Kevin Stefanski, OC Tommy Rees, QB Bill Musgrave, and Nick Charlton Pass Game Specialist, all hoped that the Browns didn't get into the Sanders thing.

 

[SoulfishHawk]

I'm good with Milroe.

 

[Ostatehawk]

I went Dart - I imagine he will have the luxury of sitting the bench and actually learning the QB position.

Sanders is probably going to play this year instead of sitting (which he should) because Cleveland is a dumpster fire of an organization. He has enough talent to beat out the other guys IMO - but that won't do him any good at Cleveland.

Cleveland is The Factory of Sadness - and Sanders is not prepared to deal with the repercussions of being a Cleveland QB.

 

[Scout]

Even though Dart is QB3 he is still going to get some quality reps.

Sadly Sanders is going to be starved of necessary reps even if he is the #3 or 4 that is the problem. In fact that is the big problem.

Sanders could be better than Dart but his progress is slowed because he will not have enough reps.

 

[Maulbert]

Milroe.

 

[toffee]

Both QB got some '?' on their game, one jumped up the draft too quickly, the other dropped too much. Neither is that sure fire QB prospect.

Dart could be the second coming of Blaine Gabbert, of course I hope not.

Not sure about the ceiling or floor for sanders.

 

[Trackhawk]

I voted Dart, but only because Cleveland. It’s where even good quarterbacks go to die.

Put into similar situations, both with the chance to sit behind a quality starter, on a team with a quality coach and OC, for a year or two, I think Sanders comes out ahead.

 

[Seahawker]

This is a great illustration to the importance of having a top QB in this league.

 

[Aircrew]

There is a legitimate chance Sanders doesn't make the Browns 53.

 

[toffee]

I voted Dart, but only because Cleveland. It’s where even good quarterbacks go to die.

Put into similar situations, both with the chance to sit behind a quality starter, on a team with a quality coach and OC, for a year or two, I think Sanders comes out ahead.

Giants have a bad record in that department?

 

[Ostatehawk]

Giants have a bad record in that department?

Yeah - but at least they have serviceable QB's on staff ahead of Dart. They may decide to jam Dart in there anyway - but they don't have to.

But I get it because - Giants. AND - Daboll and crew are playing for their jobs this season in my opinion - so perhaps more likely to try and get something out of him.

 

[jeremiah]

Well, Dart is going to spend his rookie year on the bench behind two experienced veterans. A year to learn, watch film of his actual offense, and run it in practice (albeit with probably limited reps). That's the ideal for any rookie with RARE exceptions.

Sanders is going to be competing in training camp with Flacco, Pickett and fellow draftee Dillon Gabriel. According to Deion, Shedeur is the best QB on their roster. I think his career depends on whether the coaching staff agrees with that assessment.

Zero 5th round QB's have had an impact since 2001? I think Milroe is going to be a starter in this league. He has a great work ethic, and the raw talent. He is my new Seahawk Uni. He reminds me of the 1976 Hawks with Zorn and craziness. Hopefully not the losing. Like Lockett was my favorite off the git go. He just has that special IT factor. I know it will take 1-2 or 3 years, but that would be best for him anyway.

 

[toffee]

I voted Dart. Let me guess, that's make me a hater and/or somehow racist

nah, you ain't like that at all, those are titles folks normally threw at toffee. I don't like how Shedeur talks, dresses, projects himself, or wears headsets during an interview with a future employer.

 

[SoulfishHawk]

I can't fathom the Browns NOT being on Hard Knocks this year.